Unedited
transcript
Facilitating
Successful Outcomes For Individuals Who Are Deaf-Blind:
Accommodations, Strategies And Resources
Dorothy
Walt, Helen Keller National Center, Seattle
Cathy Kirscher, Helen Keller
National Center, San Diego
Michael Brennan, Alliant University
John Reiman, Ph.D., DB Link
>> Good
morning. This is for the deaf-blind conference. First
of all if you need to move forward for any reason
to move forward for the interpreters, feel free to
do that now. If you need assistive hearing devices,
let us know. They are available down in the office
and also a noted on that later this afternoon, during
the break time they will be testing those, so that's
something you need, go ahead and let them know and
they will test that for you. Also after the workshop
we have green evaluation forms on the chairs. Please
fill those out completely so they will help for the
next time. They know what to change. And let's see,
what else do we have here? If you need credits for
coming to the conference, go downstairs to the main
registration table and you can sign up for the credits
there. And I think that's about all. Our first speaker
today will be Dorothy Walt and she is the regional
representative for the Helen Keller National Center
and her office is in Seattle. So give her a good welcome.
Thank you. [ applause ]
>>Dorothy:
thank you. Good morning, everyone. It's dark in here.
I can't see who's siting in the audience but I think
a few of you I already know from before in my region,
I maybe met you last year or two years, five years,
I don't know. But welcome to our all-day special session
on how to facilitating successful outcomes for individuals
who are deaf-blind. And we have a wonderful four --
well, I'm counting myself also. Four presenters today.
I would like to introduce those presenters who are
all knowledgeable and experienced about deaf-blindness.
First I have Cathy Kirscher. She is the regional representative
-- oh, yes. Thank you. Cathy is the regional representative
for the southwest region for the Helen Keller National
Center. And her office is in San Diego, California.
She used to be the former regional representative
for the northwest region in Seattle but she moved
to California and I took up her old position. We have
Michael Brennan who is sitting down there in the chair.
He is a project coordinator for an affiliated program
with the Helen Keller National Center at Alliant University
in San Diego, California. Michael is a licensed mental
health therapist for families and marriage counseling.
And he will also be presenting today. And we also
have John Reiman who is the director, D.B. Link from
Monmouth, Oregon. I don't know if he's in the room
right now but he will be coming in and presenting
this afternoon. So we have a full day of wonderful
information to share with all of you. We also have
some stimulation exercise if you want to experience
how to be -- what it feels like to be deaf-blind.
You can put ear plugs and goggles and maybe practice
a little bit. That will be this afternoon. If any
time you have questions or you need clarification,
please raise your hand and wait to be called on. We
have interpreters standing with me or with Michael
to give us visual information to tell us someone has
their hand up. When you are called upon, or if you
want to approach Michael or myself, please identify
yourself first. We have difficulty seeing faces sometimes.
So always identify yourself by name and perhaps where
you're from. That will be helpful also. And one last
thing I would like to mention is, we have a wide variety
of communication modes being used in this workshop
today. We will go a little slower pace so we have
respect for all people who have different communication
modes. So I would like to ask all of you to please
be a little bit slower than normally so that the interpreters
and the real-time caption person and people with FM
systems can follow everything, the same way hearing
and sighted people can follow. Okay? I have a funny
story to tell you. I travel a lot on my job independently.
I always have my white cane with me. I am too deaf
to understand speech but I do have pretty good lip
reading skills, except my vision is so bad right now
I can't read lips very well. But one day I was traveling
and there was an airline person who knew who I was
because she recognized me. She knew I could read her
lips and I was deaf. And she was walking with me from
an airport terminal and we were walking together and
I was using my cane, tap, tap, back and forth while
I was reading her lips and she stopped me. And she
pointed to my cane and she looked at me and said,
does that help you to hear better? [ laughter ] no!
I thought that was kind of funny. I think what I'm
going to do now is turn over the presentation to Cathy.
We're going to follow the agenda so when we have a
break, please respect time and be in your chairs so
we can go to our next presenter. So, Cathy. Thank
you.
>>Cathy:
welcome, everyone. Can you hear me okay, those who
are using -- anybody using FM systems in here? Raise
your hand. No? Nobody's using. We're going to have
a conflict with the room next door in a while with
the FM systems so we need to know. I'm going to date
myself. Way back in the before times I went to this
little college in Monmouth, Oregon, and it was called
Oregon College of Education back then. Anybody remember
those times? You guys are all younger. Oh, see some
here remember. OCE. Well, it used to way back before
my time it was called Oregon Normal School so Oregon
College of Education was my day. And I was in the
Rehabilitation Counseling Deafness Program. And the
coordinator of Disabled Student Services asked me
if I wanted to go to a deaf-blind camp in Napa, California.
And it was a two-week experience. And I just thought
it was going to be cool to go to Napa, wine country.
I think I just turned 21 not that much before that.
And I was looking forward to that experience. What
I didn't know was that it was going to hook me into
deaf-blindness forever more. And one of the reasons
I thought I knew deaf-blindness or I could do this
deaf-blind experience is because my grandmother was
blind. And she was blind from the most common cause
of vision loss in older people which is macular degeneration.
Md at your eye is the name sign. Macular degeneration,
my grandmother lost her central vision and that vision
helps you be able to read. It's your acuity. It helps
you see colors. My grandmother, as most people who
are, quote, blind, 90% of people have some vision
even if they're legally blind. Only about 10% of blind
population are totally blind. So my grandmother was
one of those 90%. She had taught me how to do sighted
guide with her but, remember she was hearing. And
one of the things my gram would do is look at us out
of the side of her eyes because she is good peripheral
vision. She thing she would tell me I had dimples
there your face and she would say I can't see your
dimples anymore but I know they're there. I can see
your shape. So I had grown up with my grandmother.
So I thought I knew blindness. My brother-in-law at
the time was deaf and I had learned to sign. I signed
fluently. I was a part-time interpreter so I thought
I had the blindness part and I had the deafness part.
What I didn't know is when those two things come together
in one person what that really meant. I had no clue.
And so one of the first things we did on this trip
down to Napa, California, from Monmouth was we stopped
in Medford, Oregon. At a Mexican restaurant. And the
woman that was with me, my one on one person, she
was in her 60s. Very bright, very cool. Had very light
touch. I thought, I'm doing this. This is cool. I'm
sitting next to her. She read -- she had such a light
touch. I could sign anything with one hand and she
would get it. And most people just so you know, I'm
dominant right hand. As are 90% of the population.
Most deaf-blind people who use tactile sign read it
with their left hand. So one of the things she told
me in the car, in the back seat, I had to sight on
her left-hand side so with one hand she's asking me,
she was very in questionsive, asked me my whole entire
life story and vice versa. And I told her, I said,
we're stopping to eat. What kind of food do you want?
And T.J. who was driving said what about this Mexican
restaurant? And she said fine. She was in the car
when I first got in. So we're driving to Medford.
And we got out of the car, first thing she helped
me understand was how to guide her appropriately.
Shives used to telling my grandma there's a step coming.
There's a curb. There's whatever there is. There's
a door handle. Her I couldn't tell. So she told me
things like, before you approach a curb, up or a down,
stop briefly and I'll feel you go up and down by holding
your elbow. So really quickly, she trained me. She
was so great. But we get into the restaurant and,
of course, she read Braille which only 10% of the
population at this point knows Braille. And one of
the reasons for that is that there's so much audio
information, talking books, that kind of stuff. So
one of the first things we always think about is,
oh, you're going blind, learn Braille. It's almost
becoming somewhat of a dying, you know, art form.
But people who use it and need it very much need it.
Emma knew Braille. Of course, they didn't have a Braille
menu so she asked me to read her the menu. So the
first thing on the menu was taco and I fingerspelled
t-a-c-o-in her hand. She says sounds interesting what
does that mean? What does that mean? How do you visually
describe a taco? So by the time I got through taco,
hard shell, you eat it like -- sprinkled meat, I was
-- it boggled my mind. Just the taco. The next thing
was enchilada. Okay. Yeah, what -- how do you describe
an enchilada? She had never had Mexican food before.
So by the time I got down to Chimichanga I was a lost
cause and she finally got down -- said just choose
for me. But one of the things she also said is that
I like to eat with my hands. I like finger food. Becausia
see. She was totally blind. One of that 10% who is
totally blind. She couldn't see her food and she did
the -- taught me how if you look at the plate as a
time clock, you know, tell me my beans are at 12 o'clock,
my rice is at three o'clock, my enchilada is the rest
of the plate. Got that down pretty quickly but hearing
people are social people. Deaf people are social people.
While we eat we can talk whether we're signing or
talking so I kept trying to slip my hand under her
hand and give her some information or just chat with
her. Finally she said, you know, Cathy, why don't
you let me finish eating, I'll wipe my hands and then
we'll talk and it's like, okay. That was her individual
preference. Not all people, some people want to chat
while they're eating. But you know, when she was eating,
I ordered her, I remember it being very messy food.
And I didn't order the right thing. Afterward she
said I would have done better with finger food. That
was her preference but not everybody's. So one thing
is understanding the preference of the people you're
hanging about. And anyway, during this experience,
I knew at the beginning of it my feeling with Emma
at the time -- I knew she was bright. She remembered
everything I told her. But she didn't have very many
life experiences. Like being 62 years old and never
eating Mexican food. And coming from Oregon. We've
got tons of -- nobody had ever taken her to a Mexican
restaurant before. She just didn't have that in her
repertoire of experience. Later on she ended up testifying
in Washington, D.C. before congress on the older blind
grant. I mean she is very bright. But had limited
experiences in different things. She taught me a ton.
She just died a couple years ago in Portland here.
But she was like one of my -- I thought of her as
a second grandma and I thought of her as also the
person that really hooked me in to deaf-blindness.
So what I'm going to talk about today a little bit
is defining the population, looking at the different
causes of deaf-blindness. And looking at the implications
and one thing that would help me also is to know what
the background of you all. And I would just love a
show of hands, how many are involved in the field
of deafness? That's like most of the room, 90% of
the room. Got that 90% figure down. Anybody from the
field of blindness? Two and Yvonne. A couple from
blindness. Three from blindness. Anybody from the
field of deaf-blindness? All right. One person.
>> trying.
>>Cathy:
she tries. We all try. We're learning. Anybody from
just general disability field? Okay he, three or four
people from general. So that helps. So one of the
things because most of you are from the field of deafness
we're going to focus a lot on the vision part because
that's the part, I actually, to be honest with you,
I think the deafness part is much more difficult to
learn because of the communication. The blindness
part is a significant piece and always, when there's
deaf-blindness, hearing-vision loss together, significant
impact in every aspect. So we want to hit on that
very strongly. I have a larger chart on the hearing-vision
loss population in the United States. I want to pass
these around. One of the things that's interesting,
there was only one study ever done, it was 1982. And
what they found was that for about every 100,000 people,
there's 346 of them who have some combination of hearing-vision
loss. Okay. And the larger population are people who
are blind and severely hearing-impaired. And blind
again when I say "blind," that means legal blindness
as well. It's not just total blindness. For every
person in that category there's 169 people per 100,000.
So one thing you can do is, wherever your home community
is, how I got this is I called up the statistics,
u.s. census, and the day I called it up last week
I think there were 284 million people in the United
States. This is on an I.Q. test so you should know
the range. I'm giving you the answers. 284,000 people
and simply divided so there's about a million people
in the United States, give or take, who have some
combination of hearing-vision loss. People who are
totally deaf-blind, there's about 20 per 100,000.
It's the smaller population. So we use the term "deaf-blind,"
this workshop was billed as deaf-blind, but what I
want all of you to understand is really the larger
populations, both people who are hard of hearing and
have vision loss or blind and have hearing loss. That's
the larger group. And more and more, we're seeing
those people. Back in the before times and I like
to mention, people who are hard of hearing didn't
necessarily go to deafness services. And people who
were low vision didn't necessarily go to blindness
services. And they were always stuck in the middle.
But where do I go? I remember being the rep in Seattle
and advocating over and over, somebody would go with
-- and we'll talk about etiology -- but they would
go with Ushers Syndrome, which is a combination of
both vision and hearing loss. They would go to the
state services for the blind and they'd be told they're
not blind enough so they'd go over to vocational rehabilitation
and they were hard of hearing, and they'd be told
they're not deaf enough. And it still happens. And
so it's something I really want people to really understand
that the larger group that we're really working with
these days and they're coming in more and more for
services, aren't people that are totally deaf, using
sign language culturally deaf or totally blind. This
is the bad part. There's good parts and bad parts.
Bad parts for all of us. We all have aging eyes. We
all have aging ears. One of the things that I learned
many years ago, I love the resource on this, I was
told that our best hearing ever, unless we were born
deaf, our best hearing was when we were seven months
old fetus in our mother's womb. That's you're best
hearing you'll ever have. From that point on, toxins,
ear infections, noise pollution, genetics, we all
have aging ears. So these kind of presentations where
you think about maybe yourself, you think about your
aging parents, you think about people that you work
with out in the community, we all have aging ears.
The other bad part is we all have aging eyes. Our
best vision was probably between the ages of six and
nine. And at that age your eyeball is totally the
size that it's going to be. My little boy turns nine
today. So from this point on, his vision's going downhill.
That's the bad part. The good part is that part of
what we're talking about is that the communication,
the awareness of the combined hearing-vision loss,
the technology all helps. So I want to go through
a little bit just on the prevalence. Does anybody
work with seniors?
Okay. One
person. We all have seniors in our lives. Somewhere
in our family. The problems of vision loss, about
one out of four people between the ages of 65 and
74 have significant vision loss. 39% for ages 75 to
84. And for people over 85, 52%. One out of two have
significant vision loss. One of the things that happens
to all of us is that we all have yellowing of the
lens. I used to live in Florida. And I'm sure a lot
of you, some of you who work with seniors, have heard
about the blue haired ladies. Like you've seen ladies,
older women who should have white hair but it likes,
it's tinged blue. Part of the reason that happens
as we age, we have an opacity over our lens. And one
of the things that happens to every one of us is yellowing
of the lens as we get older so some -- I used to live
in Florida and there were a ton of blue-haired ladies
as we called them but I didn't understand what that
was back then. There's supposedly a rinse that you
put on your white, you know, graying white hair to
make it more white. Well, what they see as they rinse
is yellow. And they're trying to yet that yellow out.
They rinse more and more until it turns blue. That's
how you get blue-haired ladies. So the next time you
see a blue-haired lady walk around don't make fun
of her. Just know that it's happening to you, too.
[ laughter ] the sad part on the yellowing of the
lens, and I'm going to pass these around, I have some
little candies here. Don't eat them because they've
been touched by my children and all of you. But what
is in this little case of candies are different colors.
And I want you to pour some in your hand as I'm talking.
I want you to put on the lenses and I want you to
pick out the green one. I want you to pick out the
blue one with yellow lenses. I've been told Viagra
is blue. And so if you have yellow lenses, and you
didn't know your heart medication was green and the
Viagra was blue, you see how it starts getting --
the other thing that happens is as we age, a lot of
us have more difficulty with our hands. So I'm also
going to pass around these big old honking gloves.
They simulate -- they simulate arthritis is what they're
supposed to do. I'm going to pass around some gloves.
Yeah. And I'm going to have you open -- you want each
size? We need to introduce Nancy Godfrey. This is
Nancy Godfrey. She works in our New York Rehabilitation
Center at Helen Keller. She is the coordinator of
all the affiliate programs of which we now have 49?
>> 47.
>>Cathy:
I was so close and the Commission for the Blind that
Vaughn works at here in Portland is an affiliate of
the Helen Keller National Center. Nancy travels all
over the country. And she came in to help us out for
this. So she's going to pass around -- there's one
more thing. As she have on the arthritis gloves I
want you to look at this little -- first, open this
little case. It's a little sewing case and I want
you to think about, you don't have to do it but I
want you to think about threading a needle with yellow
lenses, with arthritis. My grandma turned 100 and
lives alone but she can't thread a needle. She can't
see her medication well anymore. She's had cataracts
removed at age 90. She got busted on that because
I drove her up to Seattle and we were passing the
Tacoma Dome right off I-5, and she looked at it and
she said, Cathy, is that Mt. Rainier? And I said you
are so busted, grandma. That's it. You're getting
your cataracts removed! [ laughter ] the other thing
I'm going to pass around with the yellow lenses, Nancy,
it's a newspaper. And in the back of the newspaper
there's a map. It shows water. It shows a green area.
And you'll start to look at how difficult it is as
we age what happens. And whether you're working with
an older population or not, it doesn't matter. It's
happening to all of us. The other inning that happens
to all of us is that we all develop cataracts. Usually
by age 50, cataracts are starting. Everybody looks
concerned like, oh, god! How much time do I have left?
I'm going to pass around some cataracts. Cataracts
cloud your vision. And my husband who is significantly
older than I am, asked me one day while we were driving
how do you know when you're start go to get cataracts?
And it was night. And I said, well, one way is that
an approaching car, you see the headlights, there's
like a halo around it. And he said, you're lying.
Obviously, he saw a halo around the lights coming
on to us. His cataracts, I love this term, aren't
ripe. Whoever developed that was -- they're not ripe
enough to be removed yet. But -- but for people who
have significant vision loss, for different causes,
one of the things that we when I about is taking cataracts
sooner. Not waiting until they get, quote, fully ripe.
So that's something, and cataract surgery is one of
those big deals. My grandma still remembered and why
she was nervous at 90 she still remembered 20 years
before when her best friend had cataract surgery and
in those days you had to be flat on your back for
ten days after surgery. Don't move. And she still
remembered her best friend going through that. These
days, especially where I live, southern California,
it's like a conveyor belt and people having cataracts
removed. And so things are different these days. But
we do recommend it earlier these days than later.
I already talked a little bit about the most common
cause of vision loss for older people after age 55
is macular degeneration and I'll pass around some
goggles that show macular degeneration. Nancy already
has them. One of the things I want to tell you about
this little thing right now that we're doing, you
will have a chance at break time in the afternoon.
If you want to actually have a simulated experience
for -- it's optional. You don't have to do it. But
it's one of those things that we recommend. The other
things that we recommend is probably not doing it
totally deaf, totally blind but doing it low vision.
Because most of the people that you're going to work
with are really low vision, not totally blind. The
prevalence of hearing loss in older people, one out
of three people after age 65 has significant hearing
loss. 45% after age 75 years old and 62% after age
85. And this is something I think especially back
in the before times where they didn't have so much
hearing protection as they do now, you have a lot
of especially older men who worked in factories, a
lot of noise-induced hearing loss. Any of you work
with people who are just hard of hearing? A few of
you? Tell me some signs and symptoms of hard of --
somebody being hard of hearing. And one of the reasons
I ask this is that it's usually five years from the
time that family and friends start noticing that a
person is hard of hearing before they actually go
get checked. So what are some of the signs and symptoms
you can think about for a person being hard of hearing?
>> they
talk real loud.
>> they
talk really loud.
>> they
answer questions you don't ask.
>> they
answer questions off the point that you don't ask.
>> they
look you right in the face.
>>Cathy:
they look at you very intently. Maybe they are speech
reading. Dorothy?
>>Dorothy:
I'm Dorothy. I was born hard of hearing and my family
didn't even recognize I was hard of hearing until
--.
>>Cathy:
Dorothy said that I was born hard of hearing, the
teachers are the ones that told my parents. And hard
of hearing children are very hard to diagnose because
they catch some things, they don't catch others. They
usually catch things in a quiet environment when there's
noise around, they don't. So it depends on the timing,
also. And the noise around. Some of the things we
look at for signs and symptoms, asking people to frequently
repeat. Inappropriate response, which was said. Difficulty
understanding in groups is a big one. When there is
other noise around. Puzzled expression when they're
trying to hear something. I can always tell if I'm
working with somebody hard of hearing and they get
that glazed over look in their eye and I just know
they didn't get it. Intently watching the speaker's
mouth. Turning one side to hear better. Now, back
in the old days they had those big hearing -- like
they looked like antler or something that came out.
Those actually really worked pretty good. They had
huge ones back in the old days but they worked pretty
well. Some of the signs and symptoms of vision loss,
anybody have some clues if you're working with somebody
or think of somebody in your family? What would be
some of the signs and symptoms that you would think
about? Go ahead and shout them out. Bumping into people
or things.
>> bringing
things closer to you.
>>Cathy:
bringing things closer like to bring. Or holding them
far away. That's kind of my joke. Our business cards
are on the back. On the back of my business card it's
got large print. And it's not for people with low
vision. It's for people over age 40. Because those,
between the ages of 40 and 45, something like 80%
of us need reading glasses. So that's another thing
that happens to our aging eyes. Some of us get that
experience before others. But I'm too vain to wear
my glasses all the time. But I do have them. Any other
signs and symptoms you can think about for vision
loss? One of the things is difficulty adjusting from
light to dark or vice versa. I did an internship at
the Oregon School for the Deaf in Salem. And I worked
in the sixth grade classroom and there was a little
boy in that class who every time he left the brightly
lit classroom and he went out into the dark hallway,
he would do what we now, what I think of it as we
call it buying time. He bought some time. He went
outside the door, he fumbled with his books, he fumbled
with his wallet. What he was doing was letting his
eyes adjust. And what we found out years later was
that he had Ushers Syndrome and one of the first symptoms
of Ushers Syndrome is night blindness. And difficulty
adjusting. But at the time we're like move on, Mark,
get going! We're out of here. He couldn't. He didn't
know everybody else didn't see like he saw and I think
it's true for most of us who put on glasses. We think
everybody sees the same way that we see. Until we
put glasses on.
I probably
should also just tell you since I don't have a slide
on it that definition of legal blindness. And for
somebody who has perfect vision, we call that 20/20
vision. For legal blindness, it's 20/200. And in layperson's
terms what that means, let's say -- and I do for distance
vision, my vision is 20/20. So if they're 200 feet
away I see a cat walking in a field. A person with
20/200 vision would have to move up to 20 feet to
see that same cat. That's what 20/200 means. They
still have vision. 20/200 is a lot of good usable
vision. I also means that that person either legally
blind, that's vision corrected. That's their best
corrected vision is 20/200 or worse. I was at an IEP
meeting recently for a young girl and her vision in
one eye was 20/2400 but she still had some vision
in that one eye. Not much but she had a little bit
of vision. The other eye was something like 20/1200.
But when her mom pulled up in her white van -- she
was also expecting the van to pull up -- I said do
I need to get out and tap her? And she said, no, she'll
see it and she did. But what I would be able to see
in comparison, 1200 feet away I maybe see a white
van she would have to move up to 20 feet to see it.
The other thing is that she would have to probably
have good light. She would have to probably not be
fatigued. It would have -- there's a lot of factors
that go into what a person can or can't see. This
room isn't particularly very light. And so that's
an issue. I know Dorothy made a big point of asking
for the brightest room, the brightest wattage that
we could get. But it's -- if you have low vision,
and you have difficulty adjusting from light to dark,
this room isn't particularly bright. Another symptom,
changes in reading habits. And it was one of the ways
that we knew that my grandmother wars -- she used
to love to read Reader's Digest and my mom every year
ordered that subscription to "Reader's Digest" and
she stopped reading it. And we didn't know why well,
what she didn't want to tell us was she couldn't see
it anymore. She couldn't see it even with her glasses.
Her central vision was going. Need for more lighting.
And I got to tell you what this is another thing that
happens to all of us. If we all thought about better
lighting, we'd probably do better at our offices.
We all, again, have aging eyes. The problem where
I live is my electric bill last month was $450 and
I don't even have air conditioning and that's - you
know, so it's like we're trying to conserve energy
and both my husband and I, for reading tasks, need
more lighting so what we do is use the goose neck
on my desk. I have a goose neck lamp that has direct
light on to what I'm working then I don't need all
the lights in the whole room turned on particularly
for my needs. But what you all need to think about
is when you have somebody come in your office who's
maybe older or has identified vision loss, you need
to think about the lighting.
Decreased
depth perception is another clue. Tripping over curbs,
not -- using your foot to shuffle to find a curb,
to find the step. Light or glare sensitivity is a
big one especially where I live. A lot of people,
when I lived in Seattle, loved Seattle. The people
that had Retinitis Pigmentosa because they had problems
with glare. Seattle's a dark, cloudy place most of
the time as is Oregon sometimes. Southern California
is bright and glaring and it hurts your eyes when
you have significant vision loss like that, it hurts.
A lot of people wear visors, you know, we recommend
a lot of visors but they have to be cool visors. Back
in the old days we gave everybody those UV -- that
you would called no IR sunglasses, ugliest things
you ever saw so what we're trying to do is get parents
to give their kids, get sunglasses but maybe them
-- make them cool sunglasses. Don't give them those
big honking "look, I'm blind" sunglasses. Be sensitive
to that. And I think that's true for all of us. Increase
sunlight also damages your eye. Chris Evert, the tennis
player, recently came out and said that she has major
eye damage from throwing the tennis ball up. She's
from Florida. Looking into the sun, smashing the ball.
She has significant vision damage from all of those
days. I always look at those tennis players and think,
why aren't -- because when I play tennis I wear sunglasses.
It might be -- I don't know what it is. But I don't
know how they do it without. Another symptom is discriminating
colors. Anybody color blind here? It's more of a male
trait than female but difficulty in the blue-green-violet
range. Maybe having somebody that you live with, somebody
you work with have mismatched colors. Changes in grooming
habits. And that might be something as simple as seeing
your grandma wearing a blouse with spots all over
it and thinking, you know, grandma used to be so meticulous,
she might not be able to see those spots. So that
might be something that might signal maybe she has
cataracts going on and hasn't been checked. We recommend
all of us have vision checks every two years. So if
she hasn't been checked, that's something to look
at. Changes in eating habits. And that's my Emma story
that she liked finger foods better than trying to
find food on her plate. Difficulty recognizing familiar
faces. And one thing I do, even with Dorothy and Michael,
Michael and I work in the same office. When I come
in to his office, if he's not expecting me, I'll give
him a tap on his desk so he feels the vibration and
when he looks up at me I give him my name sign, c.k.
then he doesn't have to play that "who am i" guessing
game. People with vision loss hate that game. "hi,
you know me. You met me before." and they're going,
"give me context, give me something." so it's just
something out of sensitivity. I want to talk a little
bit about the four groups that we generally work with.
And because most of you work in the field of deafness,
the other Thing I want to tell you is that in the
back, we do have the same power point presentation
in the packet. So if you didn't get it every pun of
the presentations are already on everything that you
see up here is already written out for you. So if
you're looking at people that are born deaf, or, yeah,
congenitally born deaf and become blind, we look at
issues of Ushers Syndrome. Number one cause of hearing,
combined hearing-vision loss and most of us have,
in our work in deafness worked with somebody with
Ushers Syndrome. Four to 6% of people born deaf or
born hard of hearing have Ushers Syndrome. The hard
thing for me is that it's still state schools for
the deaf, mainstream programs, don't routinely test
for Ushers Syndrome. And so we still get people in
their 20s having difficulty and all of a sudden, boom,
oh, by the way, you have Ushers Syndrome. The earlier
somebody can be diagnosed, the better. The vision
loss is from Retinitis Pigmentosa, R.P. at your eye.
And the first symptom is night blindness. I worked
with the coolest guy when I was rep up in Seattle,
in Alaska. And this guy was 16 at the time. And if
you've ever been to Alaska, or even down here, they
have beautiful night skies. And they have the northern
lights, that aurora borealis dancing across the sky.
I've only actually seen it a couple times up there
so it's not all the time but his friends, this one
particular night, said, wow, the northern lights are
really kicking in and he went outside, he had never
been able to see stars. That's one thing. So that's
another clue that something was going on with his
vision. But he didn't know what it was. So what he
did was he went out this particular night, he got
his parents' video camera and he videotaped the night
sky. And he took the tape, he brought it in the house,
he put it in the VCR, the room was brightly lit, his
eyes were adjusted, he could see the TV screen and
he put the tape in and sure enough, on the tape, he
could see the northern lights. He could see the stars
up in the sky. And at that point, he told his parents,
something's wrong with my vision. And that's how he
was diagnosed with Ushers Syndrome. But again, a lot
of people, when they have significant vision loss,
they think everybody sees that way. Except if it's
something like, wow, look at the stars tonight, and
you're looking up and you're seeing a black sky. And
actually, that happens pretty young, nine or ten.
The youngest kid I've ever worked with before actually
was from here in Portland. She was diagnosed at age
two. His parents recognized at age two that he wasn't
seeing well at night.
The hard
part with that story was that he was born deaf, so
he had Ushers Syndrome Type I and at the time when
I met him he was going to the Tucker-Maxon Oral School.
So here he is learning to speech read, knowing that
his vision's going down. That was real tough for me.
A lot of you are familiar with the John Tracy Clinic.
They have a taught parents all over the world. John
Tracy is a young man whose father was Spencer Tracy,
the actor. John was born deaf. His parents had a lot
of money. They set up this clinic for oral training.
Turns out years later, John was diagnosed with Ushers
Syndrome. So all those years of speech training, at
age something like 40 or 50, he had to start learning
a visual sign system. Very difficult to learn a visual
language when you don't see. So that's one of the
issues why early diagnosis is very, very important
in terms of Adaptations you can make. The next symptom
of Ushers Syndrome is tunnel vision. And it's vision
peripherally coming in. The thing that was tough for
me and if any of you try the simulation later, I always
thought of the vision just coming in from the side,
that I couldn't see on the sides. We have 180 degrees
vision. One of the things that you should know that
in almost every state, they don't check your peripheral
vision. For the definition of legal blindness is when
you're vision shrinks to 20 degrees or less, you're
now legally blind. I think Michael shared with our
group recently that his vision is down to under 10
degrees. And he said yes now. Dorothy, do you know
how much of a tunnel you have?
>>Dorothy:
it's less than 5 degrees.
>>Cathy:
Dorothy has less than 5 degrees of vision.
>>Cathy:
if you even look through the fist of your hand one
of the things you can see is that if somebody's really
close to you and signing, you're not going to get
it. But the farther you are away the bigger your outlook,
your vision. So that's another thing that happens
with Retinitis Pigmentosa. You can have RP without
know form of deafness. We know a lot of people who
have RP. But will it's coupled with hearing loss it's
called Ushers Syndrome. Okay. People with Type I are
born deaf. They all have RP so that's one thing. Type
one, born deaf. Also have vestibular damage which
means the organ that helps them balance. Everybody's
going, oh one year old, are they walking yet? I had
a late walker. She walked at 13 months and I remember
thinking like, get up and walk already! But if audit
child that didn't walk until 18 months, or if you
years, but again a lot of these kids aren't diagnosed.
Their parents just say, oh. They like to scoot around.
They get around faster crawling. But it's because
they don't have that balance organ. It's messed up.
People with Type II, which is what people Michael
has are born hard of hearing. One of the difficulties
with Type II is they say you're hearing should stay
pretty stable. But what actually happens when somebody
starts losing their vision, they become functionally
more deaf. They're losing all of their visual cues
they're used to, the speech reading, the point is,
whatever they're used to hooking into so you become
functionally more deaf. The other thing that happens
is our ears are aging. And so you become harder of
hearing anyway. People with Type III which is what
Dorothy has usually become profoundly deaf by age
40.
>>Dorothy:
13.
>>Cathy:
you were age 15?
>>Cathy:
Dorothy it happen to do her at age 15. She was born
hard of hearing and became deaf at age 15.
>>Dorothy:
right.
>>Cathy:
those are the three types of Ushers Syndrome. More
and more we're seeing people coming in for services,
even in deafness, with Type II and Type III. And I
got to tell you something because I don't want to
forget to say this before I run out of time, when
somebody comes to me and they have Ushers Syndrome,
I always have this conflict. Do I refer them to a
rehab counselor for the deaf, an RCD or do I refer
them to an RCB, a rehab counselor for the blind? 99%
of the time I go blind. And even though communication
is the hugest issue, it is the issue, when you have
somebody with both hearing-vision loss, the reason
that a lot of us in the field go for the rehab counselors
for the blind is because they're used to spending
the money on the technology. They're used to sending
people for training. They know the value of it. Sometimes
the RCBs are like go get the large video or visual
display on your TTY. It's free from the state. What
else would you need? And I'm making light of it in
a way but I want you -- because it's a huge issue.
It's a huge issue. I was in a workshop recently and
an RCD in San Diego stood up and said, you know, for
our closed 26 cases, our case closures we spend about
$4,000 per consumer. And I was thinking, and then
her next comment was we spend $5,000 for a case that
isn't successfully closed. And I'm thinking, that
doesn't -- that's just like a drop in the bucket!
With the population that I work with. It's nothing.
So I'm sitting there and I'm thinking, that's part
of the reason, you know, I'm working in different
states now. Maybe things have changed in the northwest.
I've been gone five years. But that's part of the
reason. And it's part of the reason I want to hit
you guys up to really understand. When a person has
both hearing-vision loss, technology is huge. Training
is huge. That's the implication that you guys, if
nothing else that you walk away from this knowing
that it's huge. And that's why a lot of times we send
them over to the Commission for the Blind, because
they have, they know the value of the technology.
And when we show it to you later, and show you a little
Braille -- Braille display printer that hooks on to
a computer, that cost $10,000 just for the Braille,
you go, oh, my god, just for that! That's not even
counting the training. I know a lot of you who are
supervisors or who are being supervised, they deny
it. They'd say, well, this has to be -- we have to
get people up and running on that. On the technology.
Because when you need it, you need it. Some other
types of vision loss. We talked about already macular
degeneration. Diabetic retinopathy especially if somebody
developing it as a juvenile. It offer leads to vision
loss. Cateracts which we all develop. Glaucoma is
a huge one. That's another reason after age 40, all
of us should be getting checked every time you get
your eyes checked you should be tested for glaucoma.
It's one of those sneaky kind of things that you don't
feel it happening. Retinal detachment. At 17 he was
chopping wood, we lived on a farm in Salem. Piece
of the axe flew up and hit him in the eye. Detached
his retina. It was successfully reattached but that
experience led him into the field that he is in. Another
one is optic atrophy. O.A. at your eye is the name
sign. One of the things for this group, people born
deaf or hard of hearing is a transition from visual
to tactile sign. And one thing I want to tell you
guys is that touch is so important in the field of
deaf-blindness. It's everything. We hug a lot. We
touch a lot. And it's not necessarily something that
everybody's comfortable with. It's not necessarily
people that are deaf are comfortable. It's kind of
scary. It's like I know Michael, I've seen him reach
out his hand in a dark place, he can see somebody
visually right now. But I've seen him reach out his
hand and people pull their hands away from him. People
in the field. Yes. Michael said yes. Yeah.
>>Dorothy:
Wait. I missed something. Who was talking before?
Oh, okay. You stopped. The interpreter stopped. I
wasn't sure what was up.
>>Cathy:
Dorothy wasn't sure which one of us were talking.
Michael just signed yes. Yes, it's true people pulled
their hand away. But it's also a huge transition for
people. It's not an easy thing. You're used to watching
somebody sign. And all of a sudden going to this.
It's hard for me, too. I have to think about it all
the time and things that I usually do with expression,
and head nodding, head shaking, whatever. And I have
to remember to do it in my hand. What I have to remember
the very most is it's better because I can sign as
fast as anybody, it's better to be slow and clear
than it is to try to rush through it. Especially when
you're relying somewhat on fingerspelling to make
sure it's clear. A lot of people just use one hand.
Well, we have a dominant signing hand, usually our
right hand but we also have a helper hand. That's
the sign for help. But when you're only getting this
and they're not feeling this necessarily, it makes
the sign somewhat different so a lot of times I find
myself clarifying my sign. If it's not an obvious
sign. Another thing that people often do like the
sign for fine is -- this on your chest. Sign for mother.
Your hand on your chin. Sign for father. A lot of
times when people first start out doing tactile sign
with somebody you have a tendency to duck your head
so you have somebody's head on your hand and you might
be signing "fine," but you're ducking your head down
and "like are you signing "father," "mother," it's
unclear. So often I find myself with somebody who
can read fingerspelling gives them this sign but if
it's one of those confusing kind of signs like "fine,"
"mother," "father," I might add in "mother" finger
spelled.
Personal
adjustment issues. I'm going to leave that to Michael
because he did -- but one of the huge things I'll
talk about is the transition from the deaf community
into -- what? Into deaf-blind community? There is
a deaf-blind community in Seattle. There's one in
Washington, D.C. there's one in Boston. There's not
one in Portland. There's not one in San Diego where
I live, a community of deaf-blind people that hang
and commune together. There's not. So there's this
transition into this abyss often. And it's something
that pretty big. When you're talking about personal
adjustment. Also people in this group, because they
have deteriorating vision often, usually it happens
in their 20s and 30s where their vision really goes
down. 20s and 30s, we're usually just getting into
our careers and trying to move up that ladder. That's
the point that they're going to have to be going,
oh, maybe this wasn't such a good Job choice. Huge
issue for people. So helping them get into and find
the right job choice for them, given their vision
loss, is very critical. Another thing for you all
that sometimes people don't think about are the independent,
the ILS, independent living skills. One of those is
just communication. There's no book, there's no training
on how do you start learning tactile communication?
If you have deteriorating vision, how do you start
practicing that? Helen Keller, our center in New York,
people have plenty of time for practice there but
not everybody wants to go out of their home community.
So it's finding options in people's home communities
which is always our first choice. Another thing is
personal and home management. One of the things I
just learned just this past week in California, the
gas and electric company, if you call them, will come
in and put high marks on all of your appliances. I
didn't know they did that. A rehab counselor for the
blind, one of my best resources, told me that. He
told me a person just came back from training and
said now that I know all this cool stuff I want my
oven marked with a little dot on 350. I want my microwave
high marked -- she still has some vision. The gas
company, they'll come in and mark everything for you.
But it's those kinds of things for those of us who
work in deafness that we don't think about that are
critical. I have people that only eat microwave food,
period. Microwave or fresh because they're afraid
of using their oven. They're afraid of using their
stove. They don't feel competent. And when you start
losing that competency, you started eating only microwave
food, health issues come into play as well. Another
thing is orientation, mobility training. One of the
things we do in deafness that we work with somebody
with low vision, is we think Braille and cane. So
we'll send them for cane training, we'll send them
for Braille. Those are the two scariest things for
people. You put a white cane in somebody's hand you
might as well tape the word "blind" across their forehead.
And again it's one of those adjustment issues. A lot
of people even with training, they have their cane
but they have the foldable cane and it's on their
belt or it's in their backpack but they don't necessarily
have it out using it. We develop things that Helen
Keller and other places, this is a card that says
"Please help me cross the street. I'm both deaf and
blind. Tap me if you can help. Thank you." You know
what? It would take a lot of guts to be standing on
a street corner waiting at Multnomah and Broadway,
in downtown Portland, holding this out. That takes
some guts to do that. And to get somebody to that
point is one of those things that we want all of you
all to understand. But also to help somebody give
their -- get the appropriate training for it by somebody
competent.
Another
big one is people who are born blind and they become
deaf. I want to talk about some of the causes of that.
One is just again the natural aging process. Presbycussis,
we all have aging ears. Diseases like mumps, meningitis.
I was called in to a case several years back, a young
guy was in the gulf war. I think he was 20 years old.
And he developed meningitis on the trip first week
out. I didn't know this but when you're out for six
months on a ship you get sick, you either get well
or you die. They don't bring the ship back in for
a young guy with meningitis. So he developed meningitis.
He became totally deaf, totally blind. That was one
of the things that happened to him. His mind was still
iNTACt. And what they were trying to do was find what
kind of communication system they could use about
him. When I met him what they were doing was printing
on his forehead. I mean how -- you know, unobtrusive
is that? They didn't know anything else. They were
doing the best that they could. And so, you know,
another person I worked with later on was from Alaska.
Older woman, became deaf-blind at age something like
92. And she was from a group called Athabaskan. I
think it's spelled just like it sounds. It's not a
written language, Athabascan. They couldn't do anything.
They didn't know what to do with her. What they started
doing with letter to give her some choices in her
life was that she had certain preferences. So they
would hand her a can of pop or a glass. The glass
could be water, milk, orange juice but the pop she
knew. That's how they started giving her choices.
So we started using symbols for her to make some decisions
in her life. Otherwise she was living in a nursing
home and things were just handed to her. But that's
one of the things that happens with this group. Diabetes
is another big one for causing both hearing-vision
loss. Kidney failure. Noise-induced hearing loss.
I saw a young guy in the streets of Portland. I don't
know what street, recently, just this past week. Using
a jack hammer and I swear he had no ear protection.
And I thought he's going to be coming to see us really
soon like way sooner than he would think about. There's
also a group on the internet which I think is funny
now, the aging rockers. And one of the guys from Rolling
Stones, I think Keith Richards, is it, that's hard
of hearing from all those years of noise-induced rock
and roll. Trauma is another thing that can happen
and chemical toxins. I had a guy who had deaf-blind
in San Diego from ingesting -- actually I think he
had a crack cocaine pipe blow up in his face is what
happened but he lost his vision and his hearing.
Genetics
is another thing. Some of the implications for rehab,
a lot of this group already knows Braille. But again,
if they're part of that 90% that isn't learning Braille,
and they're relying on talking books and audio information,
this is, in terms of receptive communication, how
they're going to receive communication from you, I'm
going to leave this part for Dorothy because she is
going to talk a lot about manual communication and
developing but it's a huge issue for that group. Personal
adjustment issues, going from a lot of people consider
themselves in the blind world and all of a sudden
they're traversing on the fence, am I in the blind
world, the deaf world, I'm up here in the middle.
Again, jobs-career possibilities. When you started
with just blindness, and then you develop hearing
loss again, you may need to look at being in a quieter
environment using assistive technology. And retraining.
It's something as simple as, I did have a cup up here
but it's something as simple as blind people a lot
of time will pour water into a glass and they'll know
-- thank you -- they'll know that the glass is full
by the sound. Well, when you start losing the sound,
then, how do you know? They have some devices these
days so cool, you put it on, clip them on the glass
and it makes a little beeping sound. The problem with
the little beeping sound, it's the high frequency.
A lot of the talking watches, female voices. High
frequency. So a lot of people when they develop hearing
loss develop hearing loss first of all in those high
frequencies. Women's, children's voices go. Those
high beeping little noises are the first to go. So
it's retraining all of this stuff that they learned
already in a different way to incorporate the combination
of the hearing loss.
These are
people, this group are people who become deaf-blind
and actually I should have talked about the young
guy with meningitis in this group. Trauma, accident
and war. We still get a lot of different things in
that group. People with Usher II and III also fit
into this group. A lot of them went to mainstream
regular school. They consider themselves, quote, hearing
sighted and as their vision and hearing deteriorates
then they become late-deaf-blind. Again, one of the
issues that comes up a lot is, if we're not telling
them, oh, go learn Braille, we're telling them go
learn sign language. Sign language isn't an easy thing
to learn as most of us know who learned it as a second
language. Those of you who learned it as a first language
are luckier. They did a study in California recently
on how difficult languages are to learn. Spanish is
one of the easiest languages to learn. They rate them.
Japanese was way down on the far end of being a very
difficult language to learn. Sign language was right
down there with Japanese. So, you know, for years
I've been use that's correct when people ask me, how
difficult, how fast, you know, there's a misperception
that you can learn sign language pretty fast, it's
right down there with Japanese. And I still, after
25 years, I still feel like I'm learning it all the
time. I'm still in that phase. And again, one of the
things about learning sign language when you have
poor vision is, it's a visual language. And you're
asking sometimes for people to learn it after they're
totally blind. And learning a visual language when
you've never had any context with it is very difficult.
Personal
adjustment issues are huge. And job and career. Again,
all of the independent living skills training. A lot
of this group is distinguishing to immediately go
to tactile signing or tactile, some way, I have one
person that work -- lived here in Portland who her
preference was to use a Braille system on her hand.
So she would wanted me to do the Braille dots on her
hand instead of doing a print on a, she wanted the
dot for a. She wanted the dot for b. So if I met her
I would have my little cheat sheet of Braille. I'm
not that great in Braille and I'd be going, hi, this
is Cathy and what I found myself doing is closing
down a lot, because this group has speech. This group
didn't, they were born hearing sighted. And so they're
always going to have their speech. They're going to
be able to talk to you. But it's getting information
back in is what is difficult, receptive.
One of
the most difficult groups, does anybody in here work
with people with developmental disabilities? One,
two? A couple? This group generally, if you're born
deaf-blind, you also have some type of developmental
disabilities that you are also dealing with. The biggest
cause for this group right now is congenital rubella
syndrome. Most of you all know there was an epidemic
in 1963 through '65. I've heard anywhere from, we
used to say 6,000, now we say 20,000 children were
born deaf-blind during that two-year period. One of
the things for all of you, these guys are now in their
mid to late 30s. And we're finding them coming back
into the rehab system, coming back into all of our
lives. And usually, it's for late manifestations of
rubella. And it's something that when John Reiman
talks this afternoon about resources, that I think
we all need to really study up on. Some of the things
that happened with somebody that was, became -- maybe
just started as deaf from rubella and some of the
things that can happen, the visual problems that can
come up later in life. Because a lot of times these
guys don't have a way to tell you, my eye hurts really
bad. I hate this story but I'll tell it anyway. A
young guy I worked with at a psychiatric hospital,
rubella, had eye pressure so bad but wasn't able to
tell us, "my eye really hurts," he removed his eyeball.
And that's how he got diagnosed with glaucoma. And
glaucoma happens with this group more rapidly than
other groups. But all of the things that are up here,
visual loss, auditory problems come up. One of the
things related to this is rapid aging. This group
as adolescents, we saw them going into a late adolescence
where the young women weren't starting their periods
until they were 19 and 20. Now what we're seeing is
like this reverse. They're developing, a lot of times
they're very small and developing kind of the pot
belly, some of the things that are going on is more
after rapid aging which includes vision loss and hearing
loss. So one of the things that comes up on here that
I always tell people is to really pay attention to
the etiology of the people that you're working with.
CHARGE
syndrome is another one that comes up. And I'm not
going to talk a lot about it because we have resources
for it. We'll talk about the resources later on. Premaurity.
When you see these women having several small babies
being born and they're born premature. I immediately
go to hearing-vision loss. Genetic problems, birth
trauma comes up. Medical involvement issues. Go ahead.
>> I work
in the school situation and we have children with
CMV.
>>Cathy:
cytomegalo virus. One of my stepsons was born with
that and they never heard of that before that. So
CMV is another one, this little guy's only four years
old. Right now, he's only has deafness. But probably
of everybody I've ever worked with in 20 years, the
most severely disabled in terms of physical and everything.
The young man was from Seattle. Had CMV. So that's
another one that probably should be on the list. I'm
not going to go through a lot of these that I have
practical tips but I want you guys to think about
something. I'm wearing a dark contrasting color. When
I work with somebody with hearing vision loss, this
isn't -- I'm a spring. I'm a spring. I'm supposed
to wear Easter egg color clothes like pale blues and
-- but because I work with people with hearing-vision
loss, if I wear a contrasting color to my skin tone
they can see me better if they have some vision. Again,
90% have some vision. Lighting's a big issue. Dorothy's
going to talk about some of these. Signing space.
I'm not sure I even sign normal anymore because I
sign in a smaller space. So when I meet somebody who's
just deaf I don't like -- "hi, my name is Cathy".
I'm signing in a smaller area. I'm not going to go
through a bunch of these because time's running out
but I want to go through my last recommendation. Dorothy?
Okay. Two minutes.
Etiology,
always ask for feedback from somebody that you're
working with. What they can see, and what they can
hear if they have some hearing. Find out about the
etiology. Like if you've never heard of CMV before
today we're going to give you resources before the
end of the day to find out more about that. I always
-- I get calls from rehab counselors call the time
saying I'm referring somebody who's deaf-blind. My
first question is do you know the cause? 90% of the
time people don't. So it's very helpful for me to
know the cause. Not that I'm stereotyping everybody
who has CMV is this. Or everybody who has rubella
is this. But it helps me a lot to know that. I always
ask for environmental, how I can set up my own environment.
If you have people come in to your office ask them
what would help. Would it help if they wore a contrasting
color?
Transportation
is a huge issue. Can you do home visits? You know
instead of just sending this that letter out and saying
you have an appointment at my office at ten o'clock
on Thursday, think about that before you send it to
a person who can't drive anymore.
Denial
is the last thing I'll talk about because I think
that we use that term too much, that we as professionals
say, oh, this person's in denial. They're not using
a cane because they're in denial. Usually there's
a reason that they're not picking up a cane. Or they're
not learning Braille. And what I try to help people
understand is, get to the bottom of it. Find out what
the issue is. Is it the identity issue? Is it that
Braille's a difficult thing to learn and you have
diabetes and you don't have feeling on the tip of
your fingers? Find out what the larger issues are.
And on that note, I'll leave you with a quote from
Helen Keller. She said, "the best and most beautiful
things in the world cannot be seen nor even touched
but just felt in the heart." and I believe that very
strongly. It's such a positive message. I get so inspired
by the people I work with. And on that note I thank
you for your attention. I'll be back later to talk
about technology and I will reintroduce Dorothy Walt
who will talk about communication.
>>Dorothy:
You want to ask people if they have any questions
now?
>>Cathy:
Does anybody have any questions? Come on up here.
[ applause ]
>>Dorothy:
Thank you, Cathy, for such a wonderful presentation.
I really enjoyed that.
>> maybe
you want to exercise. One minute.
>>Dorothy:
okay. Okay. I'd like to begin now. We have lunch at
12:30. And if you want to be about an hour and a half
lunch. And then we'll all come back here. And we have
more things on the agenda for this afternoon. But
for one hour, I would like to give you some information
about different communication uses by different people
who are deaf-blind.
First of
all, I want to start with your environment. Cathy
did a wonderful job in explaining the different kinds
of causes of deaf-blindness and the different needs
from these groups of people. I would like, there will
be a little bit of overlapping of information because
some of the things she says I will also repeat but
they're important information. So I would like to
start now with discussing environment. Your environment
situation. How many of you in the audience work worry
VR counselor? Raise your hand? Okay. You work with
clients or participants. Right? Those five or six
people. Right?
>> right?
>>Dorothy:
okay. The reason why I ask is because I want you to
see in this room, you see, you notice how we set up
our environment here. Michael and me both of us have
special needs for visual. Environment helps. First
of all, you see back here on the wall we have black
or dark blue background. Why? Because behind the interpreter,
we need to have a dark background. I tapped the microphone.
Excuse me. We need that for contrast. You see the
interpreters wear black or dark blue because their
hands, the contrast, you see the contrast. The wall
in the background, the wall is white or beige or something,
it kind of distracts from seeing the sign language
when we're looking at them. So we always like to have
a background in the back of the interpreter. It helps
a lot to see the signs better. The other thing we
have, we set up, we had a need for close vision interpreters
so we set ourselves up. Michael doesn't need it still
as close as I do. I need to sit closer because I have
-- I have Ushers Syndrome, yes. But my RP also impacts
my central vision. It's like macular degeneration.
I can't see far away. And I have a very advanced case
of RP so in addition to vision I can't see far away.
So I have myself close to the interpreter. Michael
sat a little bit behind. He doesn't need to sit that
close. So we start set up our interpreter with the
light right on top of the interpreter, right there.
I can't see in the dark area over there. Excuse me.
You all look so dark there in the audience. It's hard
for me to see you. I will probably move you over to
a light area to see your signs.
Suppose
in your office, you are expecting your first deaf-blind
client. We use the word deaf-blind people, deaf-blind
person in Seattle because Seattle, deaf-blind community,
they don't mind being used the deaf-blind this, deaf-blind
that. It's not politically correct, I know. But excuse
me if I use that term, deaf-blind person. Anyway,
suppose you are expecting a person to show up in your
office who you know is deaf-blind. You want -- what
do you do? You want to prepare your office and make
sure it's communication compatible and to have the
deaf-blind person feel comfortable. You need to look
at your office. First thing you wanted to do is to
make sure that your sign language gets the person.
You want to make sure your signing skills are good.
If not, I suggest you hire an interpreter with training
already in deaf-blindness. Because they have a special
training to work with deaf-blind people. Very important
for communication. If your signing skills are not
good enough to hire an interpreter. If the deaf-blind
person is hard of hearing, you need to look at your
environment. Quiet environment, yes. Maybe you need
to close the door. Maybe you need to move to another
room with more quiet. Especially if they're using
FM system. If you have windows in your office, maybe
you need to close the shade. Or the blind so they
can the light is not coming through the window. Maybe
you can adjust the shade to maybe a little bit light
come through. If you don't have enough light, maybe
you need to bring a lamp in your room. My point is
it make sure that your room is ready for deaf-blind
people for their vision needs and for communication
successfully. Some of the things you also need to
consider is if your office or hallway or whatever
have shadows, needs to maybe have more light. Or you
can move over to another place where there's light.
If your sitting down in the room in your office or
wherever and you have a window, ask the deaf-blind
person if they prefer where they want to sit. Most
of the time they will say they don't want to sit with
-- they want to sit with their back to the window
so that the light comes on you and your body, your
face and your hands. You need to wear the proper clothes.
Dark color. Black, blue, no red. No red! Maybe dark
green, dark purple. If you have a dark skin, then
opposite color. White, yellow or something like that.
Important to give contrast. Especially if they're
depending on sign language. Don't put on perfume.
Or after shaving lotion, no. Because if you're using
tactile or they're sitting close to you sometimes
people don't like the smell. Many deaf-blind people
have a strong sense of smell and touch because when
you hear your hearing deteriorate you develop other
senses so better not to have perfume or after shave
lotion. If you have a beard, mustache, make sure that
it's not over your mouth. Trim it. Because if they're
depending on lip reading, in addition to other communication,
so it's important to have that. Nice beard, mustache,
where you can see your lips. Fingernails, short. Not
long. Can you see signing with long fingernails? It's
hard to see the sign with the fingernails sticking
out like this. Cut them to make them short. Also no
jewelry. Notice I have my name tag -- I think it turned
it around. Oh. In the back? Okay. The name tag here,
when you see interpreters they always put them back
there or they put them down here. So if you're communicating
with deaf-blind people, you have jewelry, necklaces,
scarfs, name tag, better without because it interferes
with sign language. You need to sign up, not down
here. Up. You have your hand up?
>> I want
to tell you about a story of a friend of mine that's
very difficult. The person was a smoker and that really
was bother some.
>>Dorothy:
yes. Good, good. Especially if the deaf-blind person
doesn't smoke themselves. So environment is important
before you start communication. You need to know the
person's background. If you know you have an appointment
with a person who is deaf-blind, maybe be helpful
if you ask questions or read information in the file
about that person's background. For example, the cause
of the deaf-blind will give you a lot of information.
Will help you plan better for communication successfulness.
Also if possible to find out their preferred communication.
The hard of hearing, use a hearing aid, cochlear implant,
can they read lips? How much vision loss they have.
What are the different possible communication you
need to know before they show up to be ready. Maybe
have an FM system in your office, maybe you might
need it. Maybe not. Have paper and pen, other kinds
of communication. But my point is, important to prepare
for any possibility you have successful communication.
So again, give you some idea. You can be creative
and it's important to be sensitive to the vision needs
because for effective communication that's very important
for the vision needs also. I would like to talk about
Cathy Kirscher talked about deaf-blind people whose
vision changed. And then their communication needs
changed also. Myself, I grew up oral. Was born hard
of hearing. I went to public school. I never learned
sign language. And I went through a public schools
fine without interpreters. Maybe my skills at lip
reading was good. Maybe I could understand such speech.
I don't know. I don't remember. It's so long ago.
But my background is oral, yes. I prefer to talk.
And later, my vision deteriorated and I realize I
couldn't read lips good so I need to change my communication.
What do I do? I decided I needed to go and change
careers. I went to Gallaudet University to learn sign
language plus. That was hard because I also had to
learn deaf culture. Remember, I had never involved
with deaf people before. My older sister also has
Usher Syndrome and she has different background than
me. She went to deaf institution when she was a little
girl. So her communication in sign language but my
family never used sign language. We are always oral.
Always oral. So I grow up, I had to change. I learned
sign language. I had a hard time, yes, because my
vision was really going bad but fortunately I had
good people who were patient and practiced with me.
So now my main communication, what? Sign language.
Later on when I become fully blind I may need to use
tactile. So now I'm starting to practice tactile.
So again, communication change. I'd like to talk about
now someone some of the different communication modes
that we will use. Before I start with that, I want
you to know about verbal messages that 7% of all messages
-- 7% of the meaning is in words. 38% is in the vocalization.
And 55% is in expression and body language. I get
a lot of information looking at body language and
facial expression. I know I'm low vision but I get
a lot of information. So I'm going to miss that when
I use tactile but that's true for many deaf people.
I talk about the different communication systems we
have now. We talk about techniques. We have people
who use sign tactile. I will show you an example of
tactile. I don't know if our interpreter, maybe Cathy.
Okay. Thank you. I use both hands because I'm not
skilled yet. Hi. My name is c-a-t-h-y, Cathy, Kirscher.
Thank you. With one hand -- Cathy, one hand. I'm from
San Diego, California. That was pretty good. That's
an example of tactile. And the other we have people
who use sign language. Like I told you I prefer to
talk for myself but I'm depending on sign language
for receptive communication. We have people do sign
visual. Sign visual. And then we have people who are
using FM system hearing aids or cochlear implant and
voice. We have people who use Braille. So first language
is Braille and maybe they can voice also, but the
receptive is Braille. They can't use sign language
and they can't understand speech so they use Braille
as their first skill that they have. Also we have
P.O.P., print on palm. You have that on overhead?
>>Cathy:
no.
>>Dorothy:
okay. Inside your folder there's a little brochure.
Guideline for helping people who are deaf-blind. Inside
at the bottom, is print on palm. I will come back
to that later. When I come down to the list of things
but I wanted you to know About this print on palm.
Some people who can't use sign language, maybe because
they're not -- they went blind first, and have a hard
time learning sign language, and maybe they can't
use Braille. Maybe the sensitivity in their fingers
are not good enough but they have good English. Maybe
later they went deaf-blind. They know letters. Print
on palm, P.O.P., use the palm of your hand and with
your finger, the palm of the deaf-blind, and you yourself
use your fingers as a pen or pencil. Make sure you
don't use the fingernails, just use the tip of your
finger here and on the top, the whole palm, use the
letter one on top of the other. Capital letters on
the palm and spell out the word. I know one woman
in Seattle who started using that. She lives in a
special care facility and the staff there doesn't
know how to communicate with her so they use print
on palm with her for short sentences and she's skilled
enough she can use that for communication. Also you
can use print on palm for emergency situation when
you signing and maybe the person can't see or it doesn't
have skill in tactile yet. Use print on palm if their
skills north up with it. Many people need to practice
first before they become skilled but it's an emergency
communication mode. It's not something that you would
want to use to replace more formal communication.
Maybe once in a while you meet someone who can't use
that form of communication. But I suggest that you
learn that for emergency situation. Anybody have any
questions about the print on palm? You see the pictures
on there have to make the letters on the palm? Maybe
you want to practice using that.
>> Hi.
I'm Mark Rosenblum from Western Oregon University
and my question is, can you give an example of how
print on palm would be used for a sentence? An English
sentence? Would you actually print every letter of
every word in a sentence or would you use an abbreviated
grammar to get a message across?
>>Dorothy:
we have the person sitting down? Thank you I saw two
hands. It depends on the individual using that. When
you print on palm, the letter one on top of the other,
capital letters and you pause before you use the next
word. Some deaf-blind people are skilled with print
on palm and can use abbreviation. You can use them
in a sentence for some people. Most people don't like
print on palm and only use it for emergency situation.
I have used it myself when I'm in a car and someone
wants to tell me something, two words maybe. They'll
use print on palm and I can understand what they're
trying to tell me. Does that answer your question?
>> Yeah,
I think so.
>>Dorothy:
Maybe I missed the interpreter.
>> No,
no, no. I think you did answer my question because
I can see how it would be very individual. If the
person signed very ASL I might use a different grammar
than I would if the person was really heavy English.
>>Dorothy:
Oh, I see what you mean.
>> You
did answer me that it's a very individual style that
you would use.
>>Dorothy:
I see what you mean. Yeah. I have not really met anyone
with strong ASL who used print on palm except for
maybe one word they didn't understand something in
sign. Or a more formal communication. How about you,
Cathy? No?
>> Thank
you.
>>Dorothy:
Because ASL is different. What I was going to try
to say before later on if anyone wants to try the
goggles and ear plugs, we have a half an hour this
afternoon if you want to experience deaf-blind, maybe
you can grab Cathy or Michael or myself and we can
try print on palm on your hand if you want to experience
that. We don't have enough time right now to practice
in this one hour but if you wanted to try it, you
can during that time when we have the goggles and
ear plugs on and then, with your parted inner, try
it with each other. It's fun. I would like to talk
about nonverbal messages. You know when you talk to
people, they're dependent on the quality and the pitch
and the range of voice. Vocalizations, your laughs
and so forth and so on. Many people can get information
from that. I hear a lot of environmental sounds. I
think Michael does also. And we can get, if you have
hearing aids on or whatever we can get a lot are information
listening to voices sorry environmental sounds that
will give us information along with a communication.
And I like my office, uses what she calls the recorded
speech. She voices it at the same time because she
knows I get a lot from her voice inflections. I can
hear her voice goes up and down. I can hear a laugh
but I understand words she says so I'm depending on
sign language. So I got a lot of information that
way. You will meet some people who will use that.
Also you have facial expressions. And I love facial
expressions. If I can see your face I will look at
your face. I'll get a lot of information. Sun deaf-blind
people can't get facial expression with tactile. So
the person who is signing, tactile to deaf-blind person
needs to substitute facial expressions with tactile
signing language, emphasizing, maybe more visual information
signed into the hand. I'm not going to go in-depth
with that. If you're interested learning more about
tactile sign language and how to use that, so information
on the web or in resources that we will offer later
on this afternoon. We have body, body position and
gestures. We have space. And your comfort zone. Deaf-blind
people require, who have -- people with Usher's Syndrome
who that vision loss needs to see a small face. So
most of the time I ask my -- that I'm a chipmunk so
I can see better. Touch. Cathy, she mentioned touch.
Very important. Some deaf-blind people don't like
to untouch. I prefer people to touch my arm, my hand,
my shoulder. Makes me feel good. Makes me feel light.
The person with me. Maybe better to, if you don't
know, not comfortable with the person that's fine.
But don't be afraid to touch to get attention. That's
deaf-blind culture, deaf for attention, touch the
hand or look up. I prefer the person touch me to stay
the hand stay on my arm so you can track my eyes up
to where the body us. Not just touch and then, look,
where are you? Oh, there you are. But if you leave
your hand on my arm I can follow the arm up to the
body and then I'm ready for communication. Also we
like to hug. Some people don't like hugs. But hello,
good-bye, important. Hugs. It's important communication
also. You remember I said before that it's important
to go slow, sign slow. Slow is good. I know many deaf
people don't like to slow. But if you communicating
with deaf-blind it's important, slow. With low vision,
some people very low vision, slow is good. Especially
if we don't know you. If I know you pretty good then
maybe a little bit faster. But slow is good. Important.
To allow enough time for communication to be successful.
Also space is important. If you're far away and you
try communicate with me, I can't see you. No successful.
Important to know the person, their background, you
know how much space to allow. And maybe not. Maybe
not comfortable close. Tactile, maybe you're not comfortable
with tactile. Too close. You need to know yourself
also. You know tactile, there's different kinds of
tactile modes. We have what's called -- hold on to
the wrist. Deaf-blind person -- Cathy, I need you.
Okay. Nancy. Thank you. I'm really wish that I have
your help. Nancy's going to sign to me. Do what I'm
doing. I missed that. I'm fine, thank you. I'm holding
on to her hand. You see what I'm doing? Why am I doing
this? Some people will start with grabbing first before
they do tactile. First you learn sign language, and
then visually, then later you field of vision is restricted
and you tactile. To follow the sign language and then
the hand tactile. You have fingerspelling. Some people
do blind first and then deaf later have a hard time
learning ASL. They will learn big Fingerspelling.
Maybe that's all they are. Fingerspelling. I know
some people who can spell fast. You can carry on conversation
with them fingerspelling for a long time. The problem
is that sometimes people don't like to always read
fingerspell. So you need a special interpreter who
will is willing to use fingerspelling for a long time
or yourself comfortable with fingerspelling. Also
with fingerspelling, into the hand. Tactilely. Some
deaf-blind people were using and they're very skilled
with that. They use abbreviation rather than spell
out words. I think I showed you a demonstration of
two-hand tactile. I used, there's one hand tactile
also. I call that a bird cage. And I told you about
-- and we have Braille. Which is also a tactile communication.
And later on we'll show you a machine it's called
teletouch and you can use that for communication with
Braille.
Okay. Suppose
you have a person who is deaf-blind and you want to
use -- some people prefer large print. You need to
know, ask them what size print. Ask them what kind
of font. Maybe they would prefer 15 to 30 points.
One woman I met last week told me she prefers 35 points.
Big. You need to have, it needs to fit within their
vision field also. So maybe you need to consider the
paper you using big paper, big paper or small paper.
The regular size. You also need to consider high contrast,
black ink. And the quality of print. And also the
color of your paper. Most deaf-blind prefer a golden
yellow or buff paper, not white. Let me show you.
This is golden yellow. I don't have buff color with
me but I think you know what buff color looks like
but don't use white because of glare. When you have
black in it or yellow paper, it's more blends in better.
You can look at it. I'll pass this out. Thank you.
Do we have someone here using an FM system right now?
I keep bumping into the microphone. I'm sorry. Okay.
Some people many use speech reading, a hearing aid
or cochlear implant. An FM systems. And then we have,
well, we have three kinds of well, grade 1, grade
2, and grade 3. We have the teletouch, the telebraille
with computer software and I want to give you some
examples of pretty different examples that I have
used and by all matter set up and different communication
in my office as I meet with their plans people once
in a while. First, I find out their background and
then they come into my office and one man himself
or, yes, also went deaf. He learned sign language
later on, went to deaf institution when he was about
15. And his name is Bob. I'll call him Bob. Bob came
into my office. And I was signing to him and he couldn't
understand me. So I asked him, how he prefers communication?
And he said, he likes the computer. I said, okay.
Come and sit with me with my computer and we will
share the keyboard and I would type to him or not
to type using large print, "choose text." and he would
read or type back, whichever he prefers. But that
was his communication preference. Later on, he was
getting training on tactile sign language. Plus improved
his signing skills. He would come in my office later
after he got that training and he still prefers the
computer. But he would use tactile sign language with
me also. So that's situation had successful outcomes.
I was able to help him. The other person that came
into my office was my mother's generation, born deaf,
using ASL but she couldn't see very well so when she
came into my office we were sit down in the chair
close together like this and we signed to her and
she would sign back to me and she would prefer to
use that communication, that way. The third person
who came in to I get herself hard of hearing and fully
blind. She would use a hearing aid because she kept
missing what I was telling her. So she preferred the
one word she would miss that I've talked to her and
told her so she said spoken communication. Then does
anybody have any questions right now? I think what
we're going to do right now is stop and later on we'll
show you different equipment with Braille, the teletalk,
the telebraille, the different things like that. After
lunch we have Michael. Michael will give a presentation
about mental health issues. And then after that we
will have stimulation exercise and I have different
ways that you can practice that you're deaf-blind.
So I think now we can stop. We're tired and hungry.
Where do we eat? Does anybody know? Becky?
>> It's
going to be the Riverview Room downstairs.
>>Dorothy:
I thought we were supposed to go in the ballroom.
>> Right.
Its name is Riverview.
>>Dorothy:
Thank you. And that's in about 15 minutes. 12:30.
So if you want to go to the bathroom or something.
>> There's
a question over there.
>> Going
back to the interpreter situation, you were mentioning
about the contrast of skin and background. Now, if
there's an individual with darker skin, what background
do you prefer? Would you prefer a lighter background?
>>Dorothy:
Oh.
>> It's
just -- I'm just interested to know.
>>Dorothy:
Best thing to ask the deaf-blind person what they
prefer. That's a good question. Myself, I have a hard
time seeing a person with dark skin so most of the
time, I don't have someone like that to interpret
for me. But some other deaf-blind people have different
needs so ask them what they prefer. That's a good
question. I don't know. I only know myself and most
other deaf-blind people prefer dark background back
there with interpreters with light skin. That's a
good point.
>> Thank
you. If anyone wants --
>>Dorothy:
If anyone wants to talk with me or Michael, get our
attention and wait for us to focus. If you sign, don't
sign, maybe we can grab an interpreter. We would like
to chat with you all. Enjoy the lunch and come back
here, please, at two.
[Afternoon
Session: Facilitating Successful Outcomes For Individuals
Who Are Deaf-Blind: Accommodations,Strategies And
Resources]
>>Dorothy:
Nancy, settle down. Good afternoon, everyone. I hope
you enjoyed your lunch and I hope you had an opportunity
to talk with people and tell them what a wonderful
presentation we're having here. Right? I would like
to turn over to Michael for him to give a short presentation
about psychosocial aspects of deaf-blind but before
I do that I would like to explain what's going to
happen after he finishes talking. Because we only
have a half an hour and maybe you might want to jump
right into it. But what we're going to do is when
Michael is finished talking, we will take a half an
hour break. You have a choice of several different
things. You can just leave the room or walk around,
go to the bathroom if you want for half an hour. Or
if you want, you can try a stimulation exercise. We
have goggles and ear plugs on the table. The goggles
represent different kinds of vision problems. We have
one that is tunnel vision. We have glaucoma. Cataracts.
Macular degeneration. Different kinds. The tag around
the goggle tells you which vision problems it represents.
There's a paper on the table or maybe Nancy and Cathy
Kirscher will tell you which one of those goggles
represent. Put them on. You can put ear plugs in.
And then you might want to do is maybe you want to
walk over to the table and pour yourself a glass of
water through those goggles. Or maybe you might want
to try to read a regular paper or maybe you want to
approach someone and try to communicate with
that person using print on palm, whatever is fun.
Then there's also a little bag of different toys on
the table. Maybe you want to feel something. Put your
hand in and see what you're feeling, look at it through
those goggles. You can change to another kind of goggles.
We only have half an hour so maybe you want to walk
around the room. We are not to go outside down the
steps because we didn't give you orientation in mobility
so try not to go any place where you don't feel comfortable.
And so we will do that for just a half an hour. For
now, I would like to turn over to Michael and he will
give a wonderful presentation. That's his field, his
background is the mental health field. So Michael.
>>Michael:
Good afternoon. My job is to keep you a wake for the
next two hours. We will have to jump up and down.
We will have a little more interactive program where
you and I are going to work together on this because
I have to keep you awake. We are going to talk about
the psychosocial issues involved with deaf-blindness.
I am a mental health counselor. I bet a lot of people
are afraid of that word, "mental health." so I prefer
to use the word psyho-social rather than mental health.
I'll tell you a little about me. I have Ushers Syndrome
Type II. I was born hard of hearing. And my R.P. showed
up about age 25. And I didn't have it diagnosed until
I was age 32. And I didn't do anything about it until
I was 44. I've had -- I'm on my fourth career. I started
out in retail. I have been a cabinet maker. I've been
a therapist. And now I'm getting more involved in
the deaf-blind field. The next slide is a story that
I want you to read. And it applies to -- it's a good
opening story. It's about a friend of mine that was
showing me his pet shark. And it was swimming around
in this -- oops -- in a small fish bowl. It's about
three inches long. And my friend said, well, this
is a real shark. It's small because of the size of
the aquarium I keep it in but if I were to let him
out of the aquarium, and let him go out into the ocean
he would probably go to his normal size. And I told
my friend, well, you know, weird or not, it kind of
reminds me of some deaf-blind people I know. What
does that mean? Any ideas? Any ideas what I'm talking
about? Go ahead.
>> If you
open up the environment, the person will grow.
>> I'm
sorry. There's too many people talking at the same
time. Say it again.
>> It's
just like an environment. The people will grow if
you let the environment grow.
>>Michael:
okay. Was there another comment? You pick. I can't
see out there.
>> It's
almost the same idea as hers. It's the same as a deaf-blind
person. If it's contained in a small area they can't
grow either.
>>Michael:
Okay. Who controls that environment? The deaf-blind
person himself? Or support people like family members
or friends. Okay. But also the deaf-blind person himself
depending on his life experiences. Yes. Go ahead.
>> And
also you would be limited by other people's expectations
or understanding of your abilities.
>>Michael:
Okay. That's true. Any more? Feedback?
>> As you
become older, sometimes it's easier just to sit in
your room instead of working hard to put yourself
out and meet other people.
>>Michael:
More?
>> It's
similar to what I'm thinking, prov theory. It's the
same as Pavlov's theory, the theory of helplessness.
>>Michael:
okay. Basically, I want you to hold that story in
the back of your mind and we're going to go on to
some other issues but as we go through the different
psychosocial issues related to deaf-blindness, kind
of remember that story.
Basically,
we're talking about people making -- making adjustments
to a loss. And when you make an add just meant to
a loss you're talking about making an adjustment to
a change. Now, the change can be very difficult. It
can cause what we call grief. The grieving process.
But at the same time I want you to remember that it's
not always about loss. How so? Through the improvements
in technology, cochlear implants, digital hearing
aids, technology, sign language itself, people can
suffer stress and grief from a positive thing. For
example, you get a promotion on your job and
you move up the ladder, it's a gain, yes. But it's
also stressful. It can cause some grief. You're grieving
the old ways you used to be around the office. You're
missing the relationship you had with your peers previously.
That's a change. A lot of times within this field,
we apply the Kubler-Ross model of grieving to blindness
and that includes five phases. This model, remember,
is based on bereavement, death. How can we apply that
to deaf-blindness? Well, what we're saying is that
the loss is similar to a loss that a person would
experience to bereavement. But this is not the only
model. There's been a lot of new research now, especially
within the deaf community or the deaf culture, about
identity. Okay. Changing identity. Whenever you have
a change in your identity, or you're not sure what
your identity is, that can cause a sense or a feeling
of loss which can lead to grieving. The clinical symptoms
of a mental health problem is not necessarily the
same as those in grieving. Okay. Grieving is normal.
It's if someone were to experience a loss with no
grieving we would suspect that there's a problem there.
Okay. So when we're talking about grieving, we're
not talking specifically about a clinical mental health
problem. However, there are a lot of behaviors and
emotions that occur in grieving that mimic a serious
mental health problem. Now, in a previous slide, on
a previous slide, you saw the five stages: denial,
anger, depression, bargaining, and acceptance. The
anger and depression, you see that a lot in bereavement
but you also see it in clinical cases of a mental
health problem. What's the difference? How do you
know the difference? Any ideas?
>> I would
say the amount of time that the depression or the
anger lasts, if it lasts for a long time it might
be more clinical.
>>Michael:
okay, so time. How long this continues on. Is there
more ways to identify whether it's a normal grieving
process or actually a serious clinical mental health
problem? Any ideas?
>> The
capacity to develop coping skills versus the inability
to develop coping skills or move on through the stages
past the anger and into the final acceptance.
>> Okay.
>>Michael:
that's good. The difference is, yes, time. The difference
is in severity. The difference is how much it impacts
daily life. Your daily living. If it has a serious
profound impact on your ability to cope on a day in
and day out basis for more than three months, we're
looking at possibly a clinical symptom here. Now,
the bereavement model that Kubler-Ross described,
she lists five stages. But that's not necessarily
so when you apply it to the deaf-blind community or
people that are experiencing a loss of vision or hearing
or both together. How so? Because this kind of loss
is a recurring loss. Most times it doesn't happen
overnight. It happens over a period of years. It could
-- it could last for a period of 50 years. People
with Ushers Syndrome I or II like myself, we've been
going through this for 40 years. Didn't know it. And
they don't know it until they're identified. And it
can happen overnight. So there's a difference on the
way that person is going to cope with that loss. And
generally speaking, according to Kubler-Ross she says
that until the person goes through all five stages,
to the final one of acceptance, they're not going
to resolve that grief. And what I'm saying is, that's
right but guess what? They got to do it a number of
times. They have to do it more than one time. Why?
So the model that I propose for deaf-blind people
is what I call a spiral concept. And what I want you
to do is to imagine a cone-shaped spring, that spirals
up. And the spring is real thick on the bottom and
that indicates the intensity of the grief. It's very
thick and heavy in the beginning. And if it's appropriately
resolved it moves on but doesn't move downwards. It
moves up and that spring becomes thinner and thinner
and less stressful until what? The loss is completely
resolved, fully blind and fully deaf. It doesn't happen
often. It happens sometimes but not often. So within
this population, you're looking at a large number
of people that are going through a period of time
that is more than two weeks. It could be several years.
And they're experiencing grief over and over again,
each time there's a loss involved. Each time there's
a change involved that produces enough stress and
it causes grief. I've never used power point before.
Okay. What are the losses we're talking about? We're
talking about loss of sigh logical security and well
being and the sense of feeling confident, okay, I
can handle whatever is the challenge. Yes.
>>Dorothy:
I'm Dorothy. I wanted to ask Michael, the word "acceptance,"
and that process, many deaf-blind people tell me the
word "acceptance," no. They prefer to use the word
"adjusted." because they never will accept. That fits
in with that process.
>>Michael:
That's a really good -- is she finished? That's a
really good point, yes, a lot of people don't like
that word. And Dorothy says that many of us use the
word "adjustment," and I have another word that I
like to use and that's called, integrating the loss
into your lifestyle. Coping. Okay. Learning how to
cope with the loss and integrating that particular
loss into your current lifestyle. That's really
what the fifth stage is. So like I said before, we're
talking about psychological well-being. I feel confident
I can do what I did or have been doing for years.
You lose that. It takes a little notch step down.
Perhaps basic skills like reading your mail, cooking,
home management, running errands, these things are
compromised. You can't do them like you did them before.
Maybe you need a little help now. That's a loss. Communication
preferences. You've heard Dorothy and Cathy talk this
morning about the different communication techniques.
Just think about that. You're born deaf. Okay. You're
fluent ASL. And you can't see well enough to use it
anymore and you have to change your communication
preference. That's a biggie. A real biggie and I'm
explain further in a minute. Same thing with hard
of hearing. It's probably even a bigger one for a
hard of hearing person to have to learn sign language.
Not an easy task. Appreciation for the visual arts
and really I should include the auditory arts like
music. Like music, pictures, landscape, it's not as
clear as it was before. It's a little fuzzy. It's
a loss. You just don't have that appreciation. Research
shows when people are watching captioned TV they're
watching the captioning. They're not seeing the full
picture so actually they're reading a book very quickly.
And if you're deaf-blind, it's even worse because
half the time you'll miss the words that show up there
because they're too darned fast. Or the wrong size.
Or the wrong color. Or the wrong background color.
Or misspelled. Occupational and financial status.
This really gets impacted. You lose that feeling that
I'm where I'm supposed to be doing what I'm supposed
to be doing and earning what I deserve to earn. Mobility.
Can't walk from one end of the building to the other
in a dark hallway like you did before without tripping
over six people. Independence and control. Don't have
the same amount of independence you did before. I
used to be able to get up, and get in my car and go
to the hardware store whenever I wanted to. Now I
got to wait for my wife to get up which may be noon
on Saturday. [ laughter ] you know, that's a real
impact on your life. She gets up at ten. Social contacts.
Remember that communication determines who you're
going to socialize with. If you change that, you just
now changed who you're going to socialize with and
it may be a drastic change. It may cut your social
contacts by 99%. Instead of having 15, 20 friends,
it may come all the way down to one. Or some people,
none.
Self-worth.
What do you mean by self-worth? It means your productivity.
Do I feel productive? When I get up in the morning
and go to my job do I feel as worth it? Do I feel
proud of myself? If I don't, then myself-worth has
really taken a shock. Contribution to the community.
How, when I lose my vision, lose my hearing, can I
continue to contribute to the community as a taxpayer,
as a family member, my role within the family, I'm
just a John doe citizen. That's yourself-worth. If
somebody takes a punch at that it's going to hurt.
We talk a little bit about culture and language this
morning. The inability of a deaf-blind person to communicate
effectively with anyone, especially people they did
before, is the most critical thing that affects that
deaf-blind person. It's also the most frustrating.
There was a time when I didn't have to worry about
where the person that was communicating with me, where
they were standing. There was a time I didn't need
five seconds to look and find that person. Really
changes communication. And it also changes your identity.
Because communication references is closely linked
with culture. If you're deaf, ASL, that's the deaf
culture. If you're hard of hearing, you're still in
the hearing culture. If you're blind, with good hearing,
you're still in the hearing culture. When you analyze
what's going on, you are really taught culturally,
you're talking two different cultures, the deaf and
the hearing culture. I'm not going to get into a big
discussion whether there's a deaf-blind culture because
we don't have enough time for that. But there is a
deaf-blind community. I will give you that. And in
some cities, where there's a large deaf-blind population,
yes, there's a deaf-blind culture. And there are rules
that deaf-blind people prefer to follow for communication
that would probably designate that particular group
of people as a culture. But it goes a lot deeper than
that and we won't go into that right now. However,
the vision loss leads to confusion about identity.
And there's been a lot of research done recently,
especially within the deaf culture, talking about
that change in identity. Starts out with, "hell, no,
I'm not deaf! Hell, no, I'm not hard of hearing or
I'm not -- I'm not deaf-blind." it's very similar
to denial. Later on, what happens? Some anger gets
into it and frustration and confusion. Okay. Then
there's this thought, well, maybe I'm a little bit.
Maybe I'll a little bit deaf. Maybe a little bit hard
of hearing. But I'm all right. Doesn't really change
anything. Okay. Later on, as the losses continue,
well, yeah, I'm deaf-blind. But I don't need this,
this, this, and this. I'm going to negotiate my way
through it. I'm going to bargain my way through the
process. Okay. And usually what happens after that,
when it becomes so frustrating, and it will, with
the -- especially with the communication and the socialization
and issues of independence, there's going to come
a time when that person becomes depressed. Mark my
words. Deaf-blindness is psychologically significant
for anyone irregardless. It's going to have an emotional,
psychological impact on that person. Whether that
leads to clinical depression depends on a whole lot
of things. Okay. But you people are probably going
to be one of the first people to be able to identify
and maybe recognize the possibility of a clinical
mental health problem. If you don't know, you ask,
you get help from a qualified therapist. Does that
mean that the therapist has to be an expert in deaf-blindness?
Not necessarily so. Although it would be wonderful.
So what kind of a therapist are you looking for? I
would suggest that you're looking for a therapist
that knows something about grief. Something about
depression. Something about anger. And then give them
or maybe they have the tools that help them to understand
deaf-blindness. Don't let it go. If you see behavior
that continues for over three months, that has a severe
impact on your ability to cope with daily living challenges,
address it. So part of your job as a counselor, as
a teacher, as a friend is to look for those things.
Because something's going to show up. People react
to stress in different ways. And experiencing loss
is stressful. We talked a lot about this. I'm not
going to go do it completely, the change in communication.
Very, very difficult. And it leads to changes in --
sorry for the delay. It leads to changes in your cultural
preference. You may have a person that grew up oral,
hard of hearing, that now is transitioning more into
the deaf community. If they're lucky, they'll make
it. More than likely, it's going to be a real struggle.
And also it's going to impact yourself-confidence,
self-worth, self-esteem. Communication and cultural
barriers together, when they happen together, lead
to social withdrawal. Okay. I can't communicate with
the people and the friends that I have before so I
got to find new friends. And the older you get, the
harder it is to make new friends. I can remember when
I was in my 20s, and early 30s when my children were
young, hey, it was a snap meeting new people because
I did it through my kids and through school. But when
your kids grow up and they leave the house, and it's
just you alone or you with your spouse, hey, it's
not easy meeting new people. And imagine that you're
not tactile and you're trying to meet new people through
tactile communication. It ain't gonna happen. It will
to some extent but many times it's just not going
to happen. I'm sorry. John Doe on the street isn't
going to let me put my hands on him.
Bluffing.
This is one of my favorites. Hearing-impaired people
-- I know that's not politically correct word but
hard of hearing and deaf people are the world's greatest
fakes. Understand. Or this. But most times when they're
bluffing, they're going like this. That they understand
and they don't. It's going right by them! Five minutes
later they say something and you know, they didn't
get it the first time.
Dominating
conversation. Good trick. If I do all the talking
I don't have to try to understand what you're telling
me. So I'm going to talk forever. Just like I am right
now! I'm talking forever up here. You guys don't have
a chance! Pretty good for me. Might be boring for
you.
Loss of
intimacy. Well, that works two ways. Jeez, if I'm
tactile maybe it's more intimate. [ laughter ] really,
no. People don't like being touched. Not in our society.
And deaf-blind people need it badly and want it badly,
most. Some deaf-blind people don't like touch. I have
met deaf-blind people the minute I put my hand on
their arm, they're on a 50-yard dash. They'll run
over anything that's in the way.
Lack of
self-assertiveness. And that's back with the faking
thing. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Waitress asks you if you want
something to drink and you say, bring me the check.
Argumentative,
weary and tentative behaviors. That's that self-confidence
thing. If I'm not confident and what I'm receiving,
I'm either going to argue with you, make my point
because you're wrong, or I'm going to back off. Another
key to the psychological and emotional issues here
is what I call isolation. And like I said before,
most people don't understand what we need for communication.
I keep hitting that. I'm just like Dorothy. Dorothy,
you taught me well. I keep hitting the microphone.
People don't understand that I need to change my signing.
I need to sign smaller and slower and clearer with
good light. And if I don't and forget five minutes
later, it happens often. Excuse me.
Tactile
signing, I can't tell you the number of people that
have pulled their hands away when I've reached out.
One, because they don't know what I'm doing. They
think I'm groping. Maybe I am! No. They don't know
why I have my hand out there. And if they do, they're
not comfortable with it. And you know, within the
deaf community, with a strong emphasis on ASL and
visual and using your hands, the minute I put my hands
on an ASL signer I'm restricting their ability to
be fast. They don't like that. I don't blame them.
But what am I going to do? You know, I have a right
to communication also.
Personal
space. Okay. Especially if you're using tactile it
really changes. Before when you had that three feet
in between you, now you might have six inches and
you're also touching somebody. It's not an easy thing
for a lot of people. In our culture, a lot of people
are afraid of it. In the deaf-blind community, a lot
of us thirst for it. The power of touch. And there's
been books written about the power of touch. It's
like a key right to the person's soul. That's why
we're human. We thirst for human contacts. Okay. More
so with deaf-blindness. Because I don't have the visual
and the auditory contact that I had before. I can't
go on the street and start licking people. Right?
[ laughter ] or smelling them. Although we do develop
a keen sense of smell. Smell perfume and natural body
odors. We can start to identify people that way also.
But so far, when you've got the five senses, what's
left is touch. Okay. Deaf-blind people interpret it
as being snobbish. Any idea how that happens? Let's
wake up here. Any ideas?
>> They
don't reach out to other people because they don't
want to be snubbed.
>>Michael:
Okay. So I'm walking down the hallway, it's dark.
I'm more concerned about where I'm going. I really
got to go to the bathroom. Okay. I've got my hand
trailing the wall and I'm looking down. People are
passing by me and I'm not looking at them. If you
didn't know I was deaf-blind, you might think I was
a little bit of a snob. That happens every day. I
went to go to the University for five years. Off walking
through the campus, through the student recreation
center, oftentimes people passed by me, I couldn't
see them. So I didn't stop and talk to them. And I
would guess a lot of them thought I was pretty high-tooting
guy or something. I'm sorry. I just didn't see
them. But it looks bad. There's no eye contact. So
we lose that sense of connection with people. Whether
it be other deaf people or hearing people. People
in general are afraid of becoming blind. They're more
afraid of becoming blind than they are of becoming
deaf.
Okay. You
get feedback from the environment through your five
senses. You get 83% of your environmental feedback
through your vision. And you get 13% through your
hearing. 2.5 from touch and so on. Whatever's left.
Okay. So becoming blind is pretty scary stuff. Becoming
deaf-blind is even scarier because you're talking
about a range that could go all the way up to 94%
or more of your feedback being cut off. So what happens?
That world kind. Shrinks down. It's like being in
an egg shell. So people, they're afraid of it. And
they don't want to hang around with people that are
becoming blind. Just like a lot of people don't want
to hang around deaf people. Because they don't know
sign language. They don't know how to communicate.
And so they avoid them. It's only natural.
Fears of
dependency. People who are sighted and hearing are
afraid that this person over here who has this vision
and hearing loss is going to started depending on
him for whatever. Socialization, transportation, running
errands, whatever. So if you meet someone and all
of a sudden it's like this, clings on to you, you
are going to try to push it back. Space. That's your
boundaries. And then this is where a lot of people
end up going. No man's land. They don't fit in either
the deaf or the hearing culture. Remember there's
only a few cities in this country that have a large
deaf-blind community. Most of the time, deaf-blind
people are stuck in their community all by themselves.
There may be a few people there but they have no way
of knowing how to meet them because there's no deaf-blind
social activities. There's just no way to meet them.
So they end up being stuck at home. I think there's
-- is there a hand over here?
>> Nick.
My name is Nick Barnard. That point right there along
with the isolation screen that you had up made my
think about the shark story in the beginning. That
there was only one shark in the tank and it wasn't
able to grow. You let it out into the ocean to socialize
with other sharks and it would be able to grow. Which
makes me wonder about more or less the deaf-blind
adolescents who are growing up in rural areas without
a great deal of educational options and their parents
have either kept them there or home-schooled them
for whatever reason. And so they're limited in those
choices without the social connection which makes
it a kind of a reasonable why people are, the deaf-blind
community generates -- degenerate to one Seattle or
Boston to that one community is because everyone else
is there. So it makes sense to me.
>>Michael:
Makes a lot of sense. And that's why it happens. But
you know there's a wide, wide diversity within this
population we call deaf-blind. Okay. Just because
a person has been identified deaf-blind doesn't mean
they're even going to fit in the deaf-blind community.
Why? Well, it depends on their communication skills.
It depends on their life experiences. Depends on their
family upbringing. It depends on their occupation.
There's a whole list of things. You know the shark
swimming around in the small bowl, okay, if you get
him out of there he's going to grow. It might drown
him, too. You know, you just can't take from one environment
and enlarge it and put him in another environment
and say, so long! Good luck! It could kill him. I
think I'm seeing more hands. Wonderful.
>> My name
is Jen and I want to do relate to the story you're
talking about. Do you approach many deaf-blind people
with the emotional level that's lower? Because they
don't have the chance to, you know, progress in their
emotional needs and socializations? Do you see a difference
in the deaf-blind people?
>>Michael:
Emotionally? Is that what she's saying?
>> Emotional
maturity, you know, just awareness. Just maturity
in general, their behavior.
>>Michael:
That's really a good question. And I got to check
my time. Take me a few minutes to talk about that.
We learn a lot from our, what I call experiential
environment. That's the experiential environment.
It's called incidental learning. For example, we see
things happening far away, we may not hear it but
we can see maybe facial expressions. Or we can see
behavior. We learn a lot from that. And deaf children
who are in a hearing family that don't sign will miss
out a lot within their experiential family at the
dinner table. They can be going like this, what are
you talking about? When is an opportunity to learn
social behaviors. Okay. So a deaf-blind person generally
has the same problem. They're experiential environment
gets limited, gets whacked around, gets chopped down.
They don't have the same opportunity to develop social
and behavior skills that matches what we call the
norm. Or what's happening out there. Thankfully that's
kind of good sometimes. Right? I mean, these kids
bringing guns to school is a good example. You don't
want everybody learning how to do that. Okay. Now,
the answer to your question. It depends on so much.
So many criteria that determine the maturity and the
emotional level of any of us. Okay. And when you add
deaf-blindness to it, I think it's okay to assume
that there's going to be some limits there. Just simply
because their incidental learning has been cut down.
So how do we improve that? They need to be exposed
to more situations where they're getting feedback
from their environment and generally that happens
through communication. And generally, that happens
through feedback. And if this person has a severe
limit in their ability to see and hear, then, the
service support people become critical. For example,
your interpret he is, your SSPs, your interveners
and your family members play a critical role in how
much that particular person is going to learn. And
experience and grow. And those people a lot of times
are controlling the size of the fish bowl. Believe
it or not, yeah. What would be natural. You don't
want this person to get hurt. So you set up some limits.
You're going to limit the size of that fish bowl but
be careful. Huh? Don't make it so small that the person
can't grow. How do people grow? They need challenges
they're capable of overcoming or capable of handling.
When you meet a challenge, and you successfully cope
with it, you move to the next level. So when I say
don't make that fish bowl too big, don't give them
a challenge that they don't have a chance in hell
of dealing with it. Okay. That's where you come in.
It requires a lot of thinking on your part when you
develop a treatment plan. I don't to use the word
"treatment." a rehabilitation plan. Okay. You really
got to sit down and think about what this person's
needs are, what this person can actually accomplish
and set your plan to meet that. If you don't want
to set it too low, because then that fishie can only
be that big. But you don't want to set it so big that
they're overwhelmed and they give up. I can't stand
up here and give you the perfect I.E.P. or the perfect
what they called E.W.R.P. I can't give that you because
everybody is so different. This is one of the most
diverse populations you will ever work with. There
are so many factors that you have to take into consideration
and you can't just eliminate them because you've identified
them as, quote, deaf. So, okay, ASL. No, wait a minute.
A lot of deaf people read lips along with ASL. Excuse
me. Excuse me. Go ahead.
>>Dorothy:
I'm Dorothy. Michael, I want to add to what you just
said that important for the deaf-blind person to get
appropriate training services that meet their needs
to help them grow also. When I say appropriate training,
I mean training that has teachers who understand and
are aware and have training in providing the services
and training for a deaf-blind individual.
>>Michael:
The people from, that have been working in this field
for many years are a wonderful resource along with
Helen Keller regional reps, if you have a deaf-blind
client, a child or adult, you're not quite sure what
to do, please don't hesitate to contact us. Okay.
I don't expect you to remember everything we've talked
about today. There's a lot of information here. It
takes a few years to get your feet in to this field
and feel really comfortable. You may only have one
or two clients that are deaf-blind. Contact us. We'll
help you. That's what we're here for. Was there another
question?
>> My name
is Linda. I want to do say in terms of that fish bowl
again, I have seen situations where that diversity
that deaf-blind and blind-deaf individuals sometimes
clip each other's fins, so to speak because of their
arguing about communication preferences and actually
making it more difficult for each other and mutually
unpleasant rather than working together to support
one another's different needs. And I've seen some
very negative results of certain conferences I've
been to.
>>Michael:
Unfortunately, it does happen. If you look on
DB Link, you'll see an article that I wrote about
five years ago called "the tale of two cultures" that
addressed that situation a little bit. Yes. Within
the deaf-blind community, we have similar struggles
that's happening in the hearing community with deaf
people. ASL, cochlear implants, speech, reading skills,
it's in deaf-blind arena, too. So it's almost like
it's a copy from what's happening out here in the
big world, yes, I agree. And some people don't want
to be in either one. Some people don't fit in any,
quote, group. And so we call them marginalized. They
get shoved off to the side. What happened?
>>Cathy:
just touch it.
>>Michael:
Okay. Thanks. And so they become more isolated. More
isolated you become, the more depressed you become.
The more depressed you become the more TV you watch.
The more TV you watch, the more depressed you become.
It's just a vicious circle. Not that TV is bad, but
there has been research that has shown that too much
watching TV causes depression. Social reintegration.
I think that's how you say that. Learning how to reestablish
social contacts with a new and prefered mode of communication.
It's not always successful. We would hope that it
would be. We would hope that the people that provide
services and support recognize that and encourage
behaviors that will enhance the opportunity to meet
other deaf-blind people or other people that can't
communicate.
An issue
of independence, we talked about this before. Just
can't do what I did before. I'd walk from my bedroom
to the living room with the lights off without tripping
over either the cat or a table or a chair or one of
the kids's toys. Now, at my house, my kids have learned.
They're grown up now but they learned really quick
that you don't leave toys laying around on the floor.
If you want them tomorrow, you put them away. [ laughter
] I have thrown away a few things in my time just
out of anger, frustration. Okay. That's that feeling,
you know, comfortable, self-confidence.
Relearning
daily living skills. That's going to be parted of
your adjustment process. A lot of people go through
this whole thing feeling pretty depressed. Maybe not
clinically depressed but just blue. Don't expect your
client to show up big smilie face on a shirt saying,
ah, I'm ready to learn this now! I'm ready to learn
Braille! Show me the way! It's not going to happen!
And you know what? They're not going to go after?
Shoot. It's on the next page. They're not good go
after learning a cane. In fact, they're going to avoid
it. Using a cane is directly related to identity.
I can be deaf or hard of hearing, and no one knows
about it. The minute I pick up my cane, oh! He's blind
or she's blind! And I have to carry that identity.
Maybe I don't want to. So I'm not just going to pick
it up and use it. Now, my situation is a little bit
different because I'm a little bit of a nut. After
denying it, after avoiding it for many years, and
then losing my job -- I was a cabinet maker. And when
I finally got to the point where I couldn't fool anybody
anymore, when I had tripped over enough carts that
are 18 inches off the floor, and fallen flat on my
face, after running into what we have a conveyor line
that we hang the cabinets on that go through the spray
booths. They built the thing so that the steel conveyor
line was right this level. And I can't tell you --
I'm surprised I still have hair! I ran into that thing
almost every day. They even painted it bright orange.
Didn't help. They even painted stripes on the floor.
Set up a walkway. Didn't help because if that cart
was one inch over the yellow line, I didn't see it.
I would hit it. So I finally told my boss, and my
boss says, well, hell, you can't work out here anymore.
I've been out there for five years. But he said no
more. Why? Because his insurance rates were affected.
And the other workers were affected. So after going
through this, I said, okay. I didn't even know sign
language. I didn't learn sign language until I was
44 years old. I didn't know Braille. And I was scared
to death of losing all my vision. But it was changing.
It wasn't getting better. I'll tell you that. And
I was driving. I had to stop driving. Okay. So when
I went in for my rehabilitation, the Blind Center
of Minneapolis which is where I'm originally from,
I went the whole nine yards. And when I was trained
with my cane, I used the blind fold. Even though I
could see, yes, I used the blind fold. Why did I do
something like that? Because I wanted to have
the confidence and the feeling that, yeah, if it does
happen, and it will, if I live long enough, I'm going
to become fully blind. I wanted to know and to feel
and to project that, yeah, if it happens, I'm not
going to like it, but I'm going to be able to cope
with it. And there was one period of time when I wore
that blindfold every day for two weeks. And did all
my walking from an apartment which was three blocks
away from the center to the Community Training Center
with the blindfold by myself. Talk about stress. That's
stress. Learning interdependency skills. You know,
it's not easy to ask for help. Especially in America.
You're supposed to be able to do it all yourself.
My god! You're supposed to be independent. You're
supposed to be at 18 you're supposed to leave your
family and supposed to leave mom and dad and get a
job, get your own place to live and solve all your
own problems. That's what we teach each other. Right?
I see --
I think I see a lot of people going like this. Now
I got to ask for help. Ain't easy. Ain't easy to wait
an hour for a ride when you used to being able to
get in your car and do whatever you wanted to. Psychologically,
emotionally, poof. It really hits. Driving privileges,
I call this the domino effect because when you can't
drive anymore, you've been driving, it changes everything.
It changes where you work, it changes who you socialize
with, it changes what you do independently. But that
one thing, changes 15 other things and by the time
you catch up with it and adjust to it, you've been
through a lot of stress. But again, maintaining social
contacts, healthy ones. Again, learning cane travel,
learning Braille, learning new technology. That's
been fun. And a lot of deaf-blind people thirst for
that because technology does open up doors. And you
people here in the room, please remember that. If
you're working on a rehabilitation or educational
plan for your consumer, it's going to take money.
Because they're going to need the technology. A lot
of it is right up here on the table. This stuff ain't
cheap! But you don't think -- you think a deaf-blind
person is going to be able to afford it? Huh-uh. We
need your help. And learning Braille is like we said
this morning, both Dorothy and Cathy, that's -- I
would say that's as hard if not harder than learning
ASL. It's not easy. If you have a Braille card with
Braille on it, try learning it on your own. It just
-- it just doesn't happen overnight. It takes time.
Appropriate use of service providers, in this area,
the problem becomes the consumer becomes co-dependent.
Not interdependent, you ask for help, the help helps
them accomplish their goals. Sometimes what happens
is they start depending on you to do things for them.
Okay. Here's an example. My hearing took a shot for
the worse about the same time my eyes really took
a shot for the worse and I had to learn sign language.
And I couldn't use a hearing aid. Because back then,
the digital hearing aids were really pretty worthless.
They're really good now. I can use a hearing aid now.
I do use it occasionally. I don't use it as often
as I should. Okay. But when I didn't use the hearing
aid and I was learning sign, whenever I went out with
my wife, my wife became the interpreter. Okay. That's
a real hard habit to break. Let me tell you. And it's
not really a good thing if you can speak for yourself
to have somebody else speak for you. Plus it's a hard
thing adjustment to make. So you have to be careful
that when you are setting up plans for your consumer
that it enables, it empowers the client to grow and
not become co-depend dented. -- co-dependent. Changes
to family dynamics. Now, that can be in a number of
ways. Maybe the person that becomes deaf-blind was
the major bread winner. Now they're not. Okay. Maybe
that particular deaf-blind person was the person that
attended PTA meetings, did a lot of stuff with their
children and now they can't do that. Maybe as a child
that played soccer for five years and now can't play
soccer. Lots of changes. So I'm going to summarize
this. I'm doing pretty good. Not bad. Okay.
What do
deaf-blind people themselves need to do especially
with relationships with their fish bowl? Well, first
of all, many of them are pretty well-adjusted. Don't
forget that. Just because they're deaf-blind doesn't
mean they're not well-adjusted. A lot of them are
very well adjusted but they could be struggling, too.
Deaf-blind people north determined by their disabilities.
Again, the fish bowl, that glass aquarium doesn't
define the size of their environment. The disability
doesn't define that. But it's really easy to do. What
the key is is this person has an ability and has capabilities
developing skills. What are you going to do with those?
Are you going to help build them, nurture them? Or
are you going to keep them in the small fish bowl?
That's the deaf-blind person himself doing that. Many
deaf-blind people will stay isolated simply because
they're afraid. And that's all right. There's nothing
wrong with being afraid. But we can't run away from
it either. Because what happens is we get stuck and
it's really limited environment. And that leads to
clinical mental health problems. Leads to things like
possibly skits schizophrenia or psychosis that needs
immediate intervention. The deaf-blind wants to watch
that, too. The deaf-blind person has to be made aware
of the it. Talk to them. Patience. Ten years ago I
had been -- I had the patience on a scale of 1 to
100 I had the patience of zero. I think my patience
has increased a tad. Okay. I'm not a very patient
person. But if you have a hearing and a vision loss,
you got to develop some patience. Because we run on
deaf-blind time. Things are a little bit behind schedule.
Things don't match schedules perfectly. We didn't
start at ten o'clock this morning. We started at ten
after ten. Why? We had to set up some communication
issues here. We call the AADB every two years they
have a conference. You wanted to see deaf-blind time,
come join us! Because somebody was scheduled to start
at ten o'clock will start at 10:30, 10:35, 10:40,
because you have got all of these people coming together
with different communication needs. And it takes time
to set that all up. Deaf-blind people don't show up
for things 15 minutes ahead of time. Usually, a lot
of times they show up 15 minutes late. Because they
missed the time, they didn't see it. They can't walk
as fast as visual people can. It takes some more time.
Need a
lot of patience. The deaf-blind person has to become
a willing participant, has to participate in their
rehab process. And that might take some time to convince
that person to actually participate because they're
still adjusting. They're still grieving. Somebody
that's in the grieving process, they're not going
to jump out of it and go to rehab and say, here I
am! I'm ready! It's going to take time. How much?
I can't tell you. Could be six months, could be a
year. Could be ten years. Could be never. Deaf-blind
people have to be encouraged to take care of their
psychological, mental, spiritual, physical and emotional
needs. Take care of themselves. Get plenty of rest.
And they have to develop interpersonal skills through
networking with other deaf-blind people through counseling,
support groups and through you? You. We need your
help. Support people. What do you people have to have
and do? Patience. Just like we do.
Respect.
Respect for our needs. Respect for the fact that I
can't do what I did two weeks ago or what I did two
years ago. It takes me more time. I can't do it perfectly.
I can still do it. I can still bake a cake. But I
can't do it in two hours. It might take me four hours.
I definitely can't drive so I'm going to be asking
for a ride or I'm going to be learning how to use
public transportation. It takes more time. Recognize
and support our needs. Okay. If we don't know what
our needs are, if we don't know how to set up a rehabilitation
plan, get help. That's what we're here for. That's
what Helen Keller is here for to help you. That's
what the affiliates are here for. Understand the cultural
difference. Understand that a hearing person, a hard
of hearing person might be transitioning into the
deaf culture or transitioning into the deaf-blind
community. Avoid the paternalistic attitude, the "poor
guy." "so sad." yeah, we want your respect. And we
want your help. And we will be all right. We will
survive. But help empower us. Don't disempower us.
That's the last one is empowerment. Help us to become
assertive, growing, productive members of this community.
And not compare us to everybody else because we're
not going to meet that expectation or the goals of
visual auditory persons can normally do. It's just
not going to be that high. Don't set it too low either.
And that's all I have. We have two minutes. I can
answer a quick question if you have any. Okay. Thank
you. [ applause ]
>>Dorothy:
Waiting for Michael to sit down and see the interpreter.
Ready? Thank you, Michael. Wonderful presentation.
You did a wonderful job. Cathy Kirscher also. Right
now we will take a break. The sign, I don't know.
But we have a half hour. And before I told you about
goggles and stimulation if you want to try that. Cathy
and Nancy will help you. Michael and me will try to
approach you and communicate if you want. Or yourself
independently if you wanted. Go over to the table,
get water, whatever. If you don't want to try that
you can go outside, exercise, bathroom or whatever.
Half an hour. We will start again at -- oh! 3:15 already.
At 3:45. And we will have John Reiman. Okay. Enjoy
yourself.
>>Dorothy:
would everybody please take their seats. We're going
to get going, kiddos. I wonder why this group of people
gets smaller and smaller and smaller. [ laughter ]
probably too much information for one day, huh? Really,
we could take the whole week to give you a lot more
information. Is everybody out in the hallway?
>> People
are eating two rooms over.
>>Dorothy:
Now you tell me! [ laughter ] it's not good to eat
at the same time, sign and eat. Is everybody out in
the hallway, want to come down and sit down, please?
Or eat it fast. Thank you, boss. Okay. Everybody feels
good? You have any feedback you want to share about
the stimulation? Ear plug? Anything you want to share
with the group of people today? Go ahead.
>> I noticed
when I put on the one that --
>>Cathy:
Can you talk really loud?
>> Whatever
the one that has the pinpoint, the R.P. one, all of
a sudden I didn't want to go anywhere. [ laughter
] and then my balance was sort of off. And I heard
a voice, I kept trying to find Nancy. And I think
she was bending over. She would say something
and then she would disappear. I looked that way and
she was gone. Then I would hear the voice again and
she was gone.
>>Dorothy:
You know many people with R.P. scan, always look around?
Most of the time we're not looking one way. We're
scanning all the time. So that helps a little bit.
Anybody want to share? You want to share your experience?
No? Were you scared? Okay. I'm going to turn over
to Cathy Kirscher to talk about technology. When she's
finished, then, Dr. John Reiman is right here. He'll
talk about resources when she's finished. And please
later on, don't forget about the evaluation form.
We want to hear from you feedback about the workshop
today okay, Cathy.
>>Cathy:
Hi again. I'm going to start with some low-tech stuff.
And Carol our CART person, she came up to me and she
said you know this morning when you were talking about
people over 40, and my joke was my business card had
large print for those of us over 40 she showed me
her funky little reading glasses. And this is about
as low tech as you get. You buy them at Walmart or
Wallgreens or Fred Meyer's. Cheap and to make it funky
and fun, but this is where we all start. We all start
at age 40 whether a significant vision loss. What
I liked about Carol's was they're fun. They're colorful
many they're psychedelic. She was a child of the '70s
and '80s. I can tell. Because I scared you off
this morning and told you that we send people who
are deaf-blind to rehab counselors for the blind because
they spend money on technology, I want to start with
some low-tech stuff. Because not everything is expensive.
Carol, your glasses were how much? $5? $7? That's
about as low as they come. Dorothy talked, some of
the things are just magnifiers but what we want you
to think about is that you have somebody that your
working with who you know has identified vision loss,
the best thing that you can do is send them to a low
vision clinic. And then they can test the different
magnifications. Carol's glasses were 1.5 times. For
me I would need more than that. That barely put a
dent in helping me out. But I would need bigger. So
we want to get into your vocabulary low-vision clinics.
There's several around and getting the right equipment
is really important.
The other
thing is large print. If I wrote any of you a letter
today, on my computer, I never type under 16 font
anymore. I do it partly for me because I'm over 40.
But I do it partly because it's easier to read but
one thing that I do is I ask people that I work with,
what font do you need? Now, Michael, since we work
together, I know he needs 16 font. He likes it bolded
so I bold everything, even if I send something to
you, Nick, and you're a lot younger, I still bold
it. And I use Arial font, a-r-i-a-l, because that's
Michael's prefered. Most people I know that is their
preference. But it depends on the font. Dorothy I
know told me she prefers 20 for the. So part of your
task --
>>Dorothy:
no, no, no.
>>Cathy:
wrong font?
>>Dorothy:
not 25.
>>Cathy:
I said 20.
>>Dorothy:
18 to 20.
>> 18 bold,
16 regular. I've got them all.
>>Cathy:
Vanna is helping me keep track of all your font levels.
But the point is you ask the person your working with.
To send out letters in regular print font, for those
of us over 40, it's tough to read. Even when I send
something to Nancy, again, I send it bolded 16, Arial
so it's something that you can all do really simply
on your computer. I have a magna cam over here. I'm
going to go through some of the technology that I
have. A magna cam is one of the more low-tech devices.
I don't have it hooked up. What it is is a device
that can read in large print like a closed circuit
TV. This is a closed circuit TV. Is that on? Okay.
This is on right now. You can switch. These little
puppies cost anywhere from $2,000 to $3500. Depends
on if you have color or not. This is a black and white
one. You can change it from white -- what's it on
right now? White letters? A lot of people that we
work with prefer black background with white letters.
Again, that's a really low-tech easy thing you can
do on computers. Just change the background. We're
all used to white background with black letters. Actually,
for most of us this is easier to read. It takes a
little bit of adjustment but when you have low vision
issues, a lot of times people prefer that. So it's
finding the right adjustment. There's an adjustment
on this side that can make it larger. The magna cam
is basically the same thing only it's hand-held and
it hooks into your TV. And with this, I can scan a
book, I can scan a can, I can scan a lot of things
and it would hook into my actual TV screen. These
run in the $600 and $700 range. Something talk to
me. You had your hand up.
>> Yeah,
I was wondering, do you have portable type of this
kind of machine? I know post people tend to be reading
on the road, driving or taking a train somewhere,
commuting, not actually sitting at home reading the
screen. So do you have some kind of device that would
be portable?
>>Cathy:
What the portable devices are actual magnifying glasses.
Yvonne?
>> There
is a -- I guess it weighs about 6 pounds that can
be is portable. It will go anywhere and uses batteries
and stuff like that.
>>Cathy:
So --
>> Is it
a laptop compatible? Can I hook it up to my lap to
be -- top?
>>Cathy:
no. What she's talking about is a machine like this.
The CCTV, closed circuit TV. But it's much smaller.
It folds into a case about the size, a little bit
bigger than this. And it weighs 6 pounds. And that
runs about how much? Do you know? $3,000.
>> oh,
okay.
>>Cathy:
This little sucker is not portable. The commission,
Yvonne's office let us borrow it but this is stationary.
This is a desk top model. And the other thing about
this is that your -- you can move around what you're
reading. But it doesn't read everything well. Like
it doesn't read cans very well, round surfaces it
doesn't read very well. This one's not color, either.
So you're not seeing color. John had some pictures
of his kids that he put those in there they would
turn out black and white. The magna cam is a little
more portable because it can plug into any TV set.
It's a lot cheaper. But you have to be plugged into
a TV set to do it.
We're just
going to show you and also we're going to try to do
this just show you some of the main things. But what
we want to get into your heads are just the importance
of, if you have low vision, how important it is to
have you read your own financial bank statement. Versus
asking a support person. Can you tell me what my balance
is? Wouldn't it be much cooler if you could put it
on a CCTV and know your own balance without the world
knowing? The trust issue comes in. And a lot of people
have to deal with that every day. You know, they talk
about Helen Keller national awareness week, a lot
of deaf-blind people don't particularly erase Helen
Keller herself because the issue was that Helen Keller
doing all the work or was it Annie Sullivan, her support
person? Most people I know don't have a full-time
Annie Sullivan with them. So they want to be as independent
as possible. But if rehab is balking at saying we
can't spend $3,000 on a CCTV, you know, again, it's
that whole, the psychological part of being independent
and doing things as much as you can for yourself.
This little
baby is called a Perkins Brailler. It's about as old
as they come. And you put paper in, you basically
can type a letter. I've had people type me letters.
I typed letters to people using this. It just simply
types Braille. These cost about $700 or $800. I forget.
They still make them and service them. And that's
a just a portable heavy device. Commission let us
borrow theirs so we wouldn't have to drag it from
San Diego. This is a telebraille machine. And also
I want to tell you all I'll just going to talk real
briefly about what some of the array of stuff we brought.
And then after John Reiman's finished speaking if
anybody wants to come up and test some stuff out we'll
plug it in, we'll let you play with it more but we
decided to save that to the very end because if you
don't wanted to do it then you can be gone at 5:30.
We're always thinking ahead. This is a telebraille
machine. And basically it's a TTY with a Braille output.
I think it's 20 cells, 18 cells. They no longer make
these. Huge issue. California still has some left.
I think North Carolina stockpiled a few so we've been
borrowing the state of Arizona just borrowed one from
North Carolina. Supposedly, they're making a new machine.
But 23 if you were dependent on telebraille, if you
use Braille, you want to make your own phone calls
and you were dependent and you found out they were
no longer making this machine, what would you do?
The emotional impact for the community a couple of
years ago when this company told everybody that they
were done making them was huge. This machine cost
about -- $8,000.
>>Cathy:
They used to be $5500. They've gone up since they
were out of business so supply and demand. But you
know, in the state that I live in, this is part of
the repertoire of what they give out for free for
people who are deaf-blind who need things. Not every
state gives telebrailles out. Not every, you know,
one of the issues is some of the states no longer
have them available. But again, it's something, and
again, if you're talking to somebody who's using a
telebraille and you have a TTY or your using --
>>Who's
talking to me?
>>Cathy:
We're doing that one next. The Braille light? Okay.
If you're talking to somebody, one of the things I
always keep track of is who I'm talking to that uses
telebraille. I type slower. Most people I know can't
read at warp speed. And I can type most of you can,
too, if you have been around deaf people you type
at warp speed. If you're talking to somebody whose
just reading 18 letters at a time that's continuous,
and they can't backtrack and read over again it's
very difficult. So keep track if you're working with
somebody who uses one, be sensitive to the speed at
which you're typing.
>> Question
about that. I have a friend who does use one of those
and sometimes I couldn't get what she said. And so
I'm wondering does it keep in a buffer somehow what
you said so that they can control the speed at which
the Braille is coming to them? Or is it just coming
faster?
>>Cathy:
--
>> This
is Nancy speaking. It was design forward two purposes.
Mainly for telephone purpose, for TTY for people who
read Braille. It's also used for communication device
for two people. They use two things come apart. So
the regular keyboard is over here and the Braille
display it over here for the deaf-blind person to
be reading the Braille. There is a way to unlink,
is what the term is, these two machines. So I as the
hearing sighted typist can type at warp speed and
it stays in memory in this part and the person can
read at their own snail pace because there's only
18 cells. If the two were linked as soon as I got
to the 18th letter of my typing it would disappear
and start back at the beginning again but when you
unlink them it stores it in memory and when the person
got to the end, they just press the button over here
and it goes to the next 18 cells.
>> Over
the phone, is my typing speed affecting their reading
speed? How's that working?
>> Not
if they know how to unlink the two portions of the
machine, no, they can read at their own speed.
>>Cathy:
and also, then you have to know that there's going
to be a delay. There's going to be a lag. So if you're
okay with that lag, there is this long pause before
they answer you back, that means they've done just
what Nancy said. The other thing that we try to help
people who are deaf-blind that use telebrailles do,
make sure that every operator, relay operator that
they're working with knows that they're using a telebraille
and to type slower. Even the fastest Braille reader
I know you can't type your normal TTY speed with them.
Okay. The new technology that we've heard about for
two years and we've yet to see it, is that they're
using a Braille light machine which keeps talking.
Coupled with the TTY. Now, for the past two years,
they're saying it's going to be out in three months,
and it will be postponed, it's going to be out in
December. Last I heard it was going to be out in December
2000. It's now April 4th, 2001. It's not out yet.
You want to talk about that one?
>> this
is Nancy speaking. This is called the Braille lite.
It has -- what is this? Is that why -- anyway, it's
a mini computer. It's a word processor note taker
for persons who use Braille. It has Braille output
and it also has voice output which I will demonstrate
in a second. So the blind person who is taking notes
in a classroom or in a lecture is typing them with
the six Braille keys. It can save files. It can retrieve
files just like a regular computer. You would name
your files and go back and find them. It's also a
calendar, a time teller, it's a calculator, it has
very many functions. And it has a port back here where
you can hook it up to a computer at a later time to
save your files to a desk, to take them to a printer.
I will demonstrate for you if someone had enough,
it's about $5,000. If someone had enough hearing that
they could use voice output, this is what it sounds
like.
>> no,
no, no, no.
>>Cathy:
cancel that.
>> 94.
Braille lite. Option.
>>Cathy:
did you get that?
>> Wednesday,
April 4, 2001.
>> Wednesday,
April 4, 2001.
>>Cathy:
One thing about it you really have to get used to
this speech. It's not an easy thing. With any of the,
you know, new communication voice output, they're
all sounding robotic.
>> During
your workshop this morning, you were talking about
Braille. I'm wondering how many of you use Braille.
You said it's like a dying art.
>>Cathy:
We still, in the field, say that less than 10% of
people use Braille. But that 10% who rely on Braille
rely on it very much. And I can't believe the one
thing we didn't unpack was the Braille display that
goes in front of the computer. It was in one of those
black bags. And that was the thing that I said if
you had a regular computer, you and I would just be
typing away. We look at our screen. It's a little
device, smaller than this, it's a little strip of
Braille. It comes in 40 or 80 cells. That's 40 or
80 different letters. It runs about $10,000 for the
80. That's not counting the computer. But for that
10% of people that rely on it, it's so essential.
Here it is. That's how small it is. And thats how
much it costs. And people shake their heads and supervisors
at rehab go, oh, we can't afford those but if you
rely on it and you want to be independent and work
a job that has a computer, it's essential. So that's
why we want you to guys to just have a little taste
of the technology so you get a feel for it but also
understand how much it cost. We also do a ton of stuff
that is very, very cheap, very cost effective. Like
one of the things, if I'm setting a white table, I
use a dark place mat. And on the dark place mat I
would set a light colored plate. And then I would
put the food on the plate. Low tech solution for somebody
with low vision. I also wouldn't give them a clear
glass with water in it because you can't see the glass.
I would use a colored glass. There's a lot of little
things that you can do that we can teach people that
are low vision.
But again,
the Braille stuff isn't cheap. But it's so essential
for the evening though that's a small percentage of
people that use it its so essential. And on that note,
one of the things that we want to do because we really
want to talk about resources, we have given you like
a tiny little taste of technology. John Reiman's going
to talk about, if you're working with somebody and
you don't know, you know they read Braille, you
wanted to know or they want to learn Braille, where
do you go to find out about it? So what I would like
to do instead of belaboring some of this, is let John
talk now about resources, and at the very end when
he's finished, what we'll do is have time for anybody
that wants to come up, we'll demonstrate any of the
equipment for you. And on that note I'll going to
turn it over to John but I'm going to find his program
first. Acuity.
>>John:
hi. I'm John Reiman and I'm here to talk.
>> Hi.
I'm John Reiman and I'm here to talk to you about
resources. I'm going to do that several different
ways. First a comment about resources. I'm going to
talk to you about information and where to get information.
But what I wanted to start by telling you I think
there's probably no substitute for experience. Direct
experience with deaf-blind people. How you get that
varies and what kinds of settings you get that in
I think varies. But I think it's probably the single
most important piece to live with, to hang out, to
play with. To have contact with deaf-blind people.
25 years ago I had the good fortune of moving in with
a family who were deaf-blind. And I lived with them
for four years. And that's where it all started for
me. Came out of that situation and got a CSC and did
a bunch of stuff which has really held me in good
stead for the 25 years after but it all started with
a direct experience so I think there's probably no
substitute for that.
Okay. Resources
on deaf-blindness. I'm going to approach it really
from what are some national, regional and local resources.
I'm power point-new myself. Keep pressing this one?
Okay. First resource, DB-Link. A brochure to pass
out. DB-Link is the National Information Clearinghouse
on Children who are Deaf-Blind. It's interesting talking
to a group who are focused principally on older adults
because the resources for older adults don't really
match the resources available to children. In the
United States there are probably somewhere between
10 and 11,000 children, birth to 21, who are deaf-blind.
For that group, we have, on a regular basis for the
past number of years, had $12.8 million available
that's funded services in the area of technical assistance,
research, dissemination. There's a state project in
every state. There are active family groups across
the country. So resource wise, the birth to 21 population
has a high concentration of resources. DB-Link is
funded for the birth to 21 population. Just let me
tell you a bit about what DB-Link is. We have been
going for eight or nine years. We are a consortium
involving the Helen Keller National Center, the Perkins
School for the Blind, Teaching Research in Oregon,
American Association of the Deaf-Blind, and National
Family Association of Deaf-Blind. Together, we are
DB-Link and what we do is respond to inquiries, inquiries
that are sometimes, gee, tell me, I have a student
studying deaf-blindness. Can you send me a packed.
Easy answer so we have packets that go out. If you
received our packets at all you will know some of
them are basic. Then we get packets and calls on a
regular basis, my child was just diagnosed deaf-blind.
Yesterday. Please help. What do I do? So respond to
that kind of inquiry. From teachers who are in classrooms
with deaf-blind children. Help. I have a deaf-blind
child in my classroom. Where do I begin? Now, to answer
these inquiries, we have a staff of information specialists
who are highly trained folks who conduct pretty lengthy
interviews with people inquiring for information to
find out exactly what it is they want. And then we
go about responding to those inquiries. How? We send
information. We have databases that we've developed.
If you have ever been to our DB-Link website, very
in depth deaf-blind focused websites. Principally
child focused but with a huge amount of information
relevant to an older population as well. We also publish
quite a bit. We publish things called basically fact
sheets and publish things as straightforward as overview
on deaf-blindness, which is a pretty straightforward
explanation of a lot of issues related to deaf-blindness.
And we also like publishing more esoteric things.
I have recently done one that is considerably more
abstract but very interesting and engaging called
"the importance of hands for the person who is deaf-blind."
so we publish a lot of materials as well. We also
publish a newsletter that comes out on a regular basis.
And this is called Deaf-Blind Perspectives. How many
of you have seen it? Okay. Some. We publish this on
a regular basis and all these materials are available
in different fonts. They're available in Braille.
We send disks out. And we get requests from all over
the world and we have rapidly increasing number of
requests, people accessing our databases and requesting
materials from us. The issue I'm passing out to you
now is an issue relevant to what we're talking about
here. The lead article in the fall 2001 issue is "the
group for students with Ushers Syndrome, South Louisiana."
so we solicit articles and we also have people coming
to us requesting they write articles. The thing about
information, and I don't know how to say this, I guess
I'll just say it. My experience has been as a practitioner
and as a researcher and now as an administrator, in
areas related to deafness and deaf-blindness that
was an awful lot of recycled conventional wisdom about
deaf people and about deaf-blind people that's not
written by or coming from the perspective of deaf
or deaf-blind people. It's been around for a very,
very long time. And that has within it some notions
about the needs of deaf and deaf-blind people that
aren't reflected of, a, the actual life experiences
of a lot of people living in the world right now;
b, that don't reflect very much good research in terms
of really looking at things from a different perspective;
and, c, materials that aren't often useful right now.
So information and everything is we have in the databases
that we publish useful? We would hope so. But we're
not screening everything either. We try to make a
lot of materials available. How do you contact DB-Link?
On the back side of the little brochure you'll see
an 800 toll free voice line. We also have an 800 TTY
line. And then you can call DB-Link from 9 to 5. Again
the types of inquiries we respond to, even though
our funding its birth to 21 we're bleeding over into
a lot of issues related to children who aren't children
anymore, kids in their young 20s, transition age because
as the population begins to get into more services,
post secondary education, more employment opportunities,
the world is largely saying, well, gosh, what do we
do? How do we deal with this? There is not a DB-Link
counter part dealing with the adult population with
the exception of the Helen Keller Center that does
a remarkable job of providing information relative
to that population. However, the Helen Keller National
Center, and if you look on the back of this, we have
a little practice that says, given DB-Link's specific
focus on children, if you have questions related to
adults who are deaf-blind, contacted the Helen Keller
National Center. That said the Helen Keller National
Center doesn't have the $400,000 a year that DB-Link
has to run a specific national information center.
I guess I would like at this point to call forward
that beautiful graphic that's relevant. So Helen Keller,
I'll give it to Cathy for a second.
>>Cathy:
I just wanted to tell you really briefly what we do.
We have ten regions in the country. Dorothy is a regional
rep for the northwest region. I used to do that same
job. I'm the regional rep for southwest region. For
me I have Hawaii as one of my states. Poor me. Somebody
has to do it. What we do as regional reps is basically
advocacy, resource, we do a ton of training like this.
We get called in on cases. But the one thing we want
all of you to think about and what's in your packed,
we have a national registry of people who are deaf-blind.
And we included a short form if your registry that
what we would ask you if you're working with somebody
that you know has both combined hearing-vision loss
and with their permission, if you would ask them to
fill out the short form or help them fill out the
short form, we have it set up so it's sent back to
Dorothy. Since most of you are in Dorothy's region.
Because one of the issues is, we should know about
a million people in the United States. I think the
last count we had about 12,000 on the national registry.
The more that we have the more money, the more services
we can use to develop for this population, which is
a huge issue. The other thing I want to tell you about
is we have our national training center on Long Island,
New York. People that go there, students that go,
we take 42 students at a time. Generally, funded by
vocational rehabilitation. It costs $550 a week to
send someone there. For room, board, evaluation, training.
After the initial eight-week evaluation, what we do
is a conference call with the team. All of the teachers
at Helen Keller, the student, the team back home,
and the region a.m. rep, and a decision is made whether
the student needs additional training. Generally,
people stay about nine months. Some people much less.
Some people longer. So if you have a student that
is highly independent and they want to go really to
focus on technology, and focus on learning Braille,
their state probably would be shorter stay would be
probably shorter. Our training periods are 13 weeks
at a time and again at the end of the 13 weeks we'll
do a conference call with everybody involved. And
make a decision should there be extended training.
But what we really look for first, I got to tell you,
I was regional rep in Seattle for seven years. I never
referred one person to the National Center. And it
wasn't because I didn't believe in the National Center.
I think we have a great program. But at the time we
had some pretty great services in Seattle. In Idaho
even. In Alaska. And in Oregon. We're finding out
about more and more people with diverse needs, and
sometimes we can't meet everybody's need in their
home community. Home community training is always
our first option and it's always what we will help
connect you with. And if that means Dorothy or I going
in and doing training with the service agency, we
can do that. But if all else fails, what we do is
have a person look at the national training center
in New York. Right now there's about a one-year waiting
list to get in. So if you even think you have somebody
that might need to go to New York for training, what
I generally do is have people fill out an application,
then what it does is give us a year to look for community
resources. And at the end of that year, we don't have
them, let's look at the possibility of sending that
person for training in New York. We also have a summer
teen program, eight-week evaluation, and a two-week
orientation for teens. So if you wanted to know more,
we've got Dorothy's name on the website. We've got
her e-mail address. Please contact us. For us to come
into your region, it's no cost. Just as DB-Link, there's
not a cost. We're federally funded. The only cost
for Helen Keller is for a student to actually go there
for training.
>>John:
thanks, Cathy. NTAC, another resource. If you know
of children who are deaf-blind in your state, they
are able to, through the state, contact this national
technical assistance consortium. And in your packet,
as a contact person for several of the states. What
is NTAC? The government provides four NTAC about $1.5
million a year for assistance to children in states.
What kind of assistance? Technical assistance that
would, for example, help a classroom become accessible
to deaf-blind children, to change overall systems
and how open they are to working with deaf-blind children.
Each state, each state also has a deaf-blind coordinator
for the birth to 21 population. And this person provides
consultation, information, referral, technical assistance
and so forth. Here's a key piece. I've told you that
there's this huge amount of resource dedicated to
children birth to 21. When we look at the population
of deaf-blind kids birth to 21, a huge percent of
that group, maybe 80% or as many as 80%, have additional
challenges as well. Some of them have cognitive challenges.
About 80% have additional or secondary challenges
in addition to deaf-blindness. Okay? The difficulty
comes with once you leave the birth to 21 group, what
kind of resources do you have? Helen Keller is a phenomenal
resource. But there's not, for example, someone in
each state. I suppose within VR or within bureau for
the blind, in many cases there are people able to
deal with and serve those folks. But I don't think
that there's a huge budget to go with it. Or a national
set of resources to go with it. I guess what I would
love would be if there was some way you were to leave
here and cohese into a lobby able to try to impact
government sources to get the same level and types
of services that the kids have gotten. Why do the
kids have so much more in the way of services? Largely
I think because of their families, their parents who
are a huge lobby. What voice do deaf-blind adults
have in the world in terms of self advocates? Well,
I guess if you look back at how you've been enculturated
as a deaf-blind adult -- deaf-blind child, you haven't
really learn add great deal through your schooling
and being in a family who's probably more hearing
than not to -- of how to self-advocate and how to
self determine. It's another topic but I would love
to see as much resource available as there is to kids.
And there are some resources in the states for that.
National family association for the deaf-blind, this
is the national organization of families pretty much
families with -- well, I guess families with children
of all ages, really. A lot of them are in the birth
to 21 zone. But this is the national family association.
Of children who are deaf-blind. There's the contact
information. And they have a website, too. For those
of you who like the internet, through DB-Link, we
have a number of listservs. How many of you know what
a listserv is? So a listserv is an opportunity to
network on the computer, and we have an e-mail connected,
to, with people from all over the world interested
in the same thing and looking at the same kind of
needs. And we have several of these. We have one called
a DB-list and if you want to see what it's like, just
look at instructions in the handout you have. Leave
the subject line blank and try it. Down load it. It
doesn't cost you anything but you become privy in
a heartbeat to what the dialogue looks like between
deaf-blind people, their service providers, their
families, it's not to say that there aren't, of course,
lots of additional dialogues going on off the listserv
but this listserv is extremely busy. There's also
an Ushers Syndrome listserv, particularly people with
Ushers Syndrome. National organizations. American
association of the deaf-blind. How many of you have
heard of AADB? Okay. So not everybody at all. American
association for the deaf-blind is the national organization
for people who are deaf-blind. What does the organization
do? Well, increasingly, it is serving as an opportunity
for deaf-blind people to come together every couple
of years for an incredible convention, a convention
probably unlike anything that you've ever been to.
You basically live with deaf-blind folks, several
hundred of them and probably -- I think the last one
there were maybe 300 deaf-blind people and 700 or
800 support service people so about 1100 or 1200 people
and you can really go and volunteer with any level
of knowledge or expertise if you're a typist you could
actually type much like the person here is typing.
You could go interpret. You could go and play. It's
a remarkable experience. And I think that for anybody
anticipating having contact with deaf-blind people,
it's a great first step. AADB is also hopefully going
to go in the direction of being a lobbying agent and
trying to up the level of services available to deaf-blind
people. We're having some conversations now. DB-Link
has a contract with AADB and AADB under that contract
is now develop act mentoring program. A mentoring
program so that deaf-blind adults are able to teach
leadership skills and work with younger deaf-blind
people. Two other resources are self-help for hard
of hearing whose address and website we have there
as well as the association for late-deafened adults
and again with these, if you have a computer, drop
in on their websites. There are also state consumer
organizations related to deaf-blind people. Example,
deaf-blind people of Oregon and Washington state deaf-blind
citizens, which I think is one of the most active
in the country. Aids and devices, here's a catalog
that you can get by calling an 800 number. And you
can get a look at an incredible number of very neat
products, well-described and easily accessible. And
another company, too, called Maxiaids. So let me just
check in with you. Resourcewise, I guess what you've
seen are some examples of the kinds of publications
DB-Link does. Some listing of the kinds of possibilities
there are as far as places to contacted. And I guess
my imploring you to find whatever means you can get
to get progressively involved with people who are
deaf-blind. I think you'll be very surprised at the
level of receptivity you meet from deaf-blind people
who are -- you know, I told you 25 years ago I walked
into, I was in Tallahassee, Florida, and I was working
as a therapist in a state hospital and there were
a lot of people hospitalized, in fact, there were
85 in this hospital. I thought that didn't make any
sense. So I went to a meeting of the Tallahassee Association
of the Deaf. I didn't know a sign in the world. Just
wrote things like on a little notepad. I want to learn
sign language. How do I do it? Where do I go? And
just lucked out because the people I wrote to, their
daughter was moving off to college and he was deaf-blind
and she was deaf and they were the president and vice
president of the Tallahassee Association of the Deaf
and they had an extra room and I moved in with them
and that was it. And I can't tell you how much of
a value I place on that early, on that early experience.
And continue to at every opportunity. Mitch Turbin,
you may have met him. He's a deaf-blind man here in
Portland. Stopped by earlier and asked that I highlight
for you -- I don't have enough of them to pass out,
the availability in Oregon -- I guessing you don't
have to be from Oregon to go to deaf-blind camp May
4th through 6th. And here's an application. Deadline
if you didn't want to wait and go to AADB here's a
great opportunity to get involved locally and Mitch
has also put his business card in here. So one other
comment. Internationally, the amount of traffic DB-Link
has seen in the last year is just growing exponentially.
In fact, we've had people come from the Danish Center
that parallels what DB-Link does. And the Nordic Center
and increasingly, the world is beginning to share
resources and I would have thought ten years ago that
we were probably more sophisticated just because of
my own I guess American enthocentricity or just that
we know the most but it's been lovely and refreshing
to find out how complimentary the information throughout
the world is. Fourth of July Jordie Xena.
>>Cathy:
my daughter and dog.
>>John:
I think that's probably a subtle reminder. Thanks,
Cathy. I guess your ready. [ laughter ] okay. Thank
you very much. [ applause ]
>>Dorothy:
thank you, John. You did a wonderful job. Always,
always, always good job.
>>John:
thank you.
>>Dorothy:
did you take my agenda? Okay. I got it. Thank you.
I'm supposed to memorize this but I didn't. Okay.
I think that's finished. What I would like to do right
now is we are going to have wrap-up and then we're
going to have our time for any questions and answer
if you have any questions now is a good time to ask
all of us. Any one of us. We have really given you
a lot of information today. Maybe you're overwhelmed.
And I hope you learned something today and I hope
you enjoyed yourself also. We have an evaluation form.
Please fill that out. We have technology equipment
there if you wanted to come up and practice anything
you have. If you are tired and you wanted to leave,
that's fine. Wherever you want. We will see you around.
Tomorrow afternoon, time, 2:30 to 3:45, I think, myself
and a woman from Seattle agency called deaf-blind
service center, Nancy sommers, she and I will give
a presentation called "support service providers and
interveners." so if you are interested in learning
about that you are welcome to come tomorrow afternoon.
Thank you for coming today and hopefully we see you
again around. If you have any questions to ask now
is a good time. Everybody's tired. [ laughter ] okay.
We have one.
>> what
time is the conference tomorrow?
>>Dorothy:
starts in the morning I think 8:30, I think. Oh, the
presentation? In the afternoon, it's 2:45 -- no. It's
in the schedule. I think 2:30 to 3:45. Okay. Thank
you. Thank you. 2:30. Finished. Deaf-blind people,
we do -- for applause. Thank you to Michael, Cathy
and John Reiman for their presentation today. And
thanks the interpreters. I had so many interpreters
I can't even count them.
>>John:
we love interpreters.
>>Dorothy:
that's a good question. Put them on the table over
there.